|
2002 Congress Abstracts
1
END OF LIFE (EOL) NURSING EDUCATION CONSORTIUM (ELNEC). Rose Virani, RNc,
MHA, OCN®, Betty R. Ferrell, PhD, FAAN, and Marcia Grant, DNSc, FAAN,
City of Hope National Medical Center, Duarte, CA.
Previous research has demonstrated that nursing education has not prepared
nurses to provide optimum EOL care; and yet, care of patients at the EOL
is contingent on adequate preparation of healthcare providers. To date,
there has not been a unified or organized effort to broadly address the
preparation of nurses in EOL care. The purpose of this Robert Wood Johnson
Foundation-funded project (2000–2003) is to develop and implement
a comprehensive national effort to improve EOL care by nurses through
a joint collaboration between the American Association of Colleges of
Nursing (AACN) and the City of Hope Cancer Center. Based on the AACN “Peaceful
Death” document, the ELNEC curriculum focuses on nine EOL core areas:
nursing care at EOL; pain management; symptom management; ethical/legal
issues; cultural considerations; communication; grief, loss, and bereavement;
preparation and care for the time of death; and achieving quality care
at the EOL. This project is a synthesis of research and knowledge in EOL
care and is intended to assist clinical nurses with implementing scientifically
based care in practice. Eight national training courses follow the development
of the core training curriculum to enhance EOL expertise in faculty in
undergraduate nursing programs (five courses) as well as in continuing
education programs (two courses) and the National Council of State Boards
of Nursing, Inc. staff and state boards (one course). Development of the
ELNEC program includes detailed teaching materials to integrate EOL content
into existing nursing curricula and clinical teaching. The projected outreach
is to 135,000 registered nurses who will receive EOL training/education
through schools’ or agencies’ educational programs as a result
of these eight training programs. This presentation will provide description
of evaluation methods as well as preliminary results for the five undergraduate
courses: standard course evaluation summaries; curriculum surveys conducted
pre-course and at 12 months; and participant goals conducted pre-course,
immediate post-course, and at six and 12 month post course. This national
organized effort is a major step toward preparing nurses in EOL care to
improve care of the dying.
2
IMPROVING CARDIOPULMONARY RESUSCITATION SERVICES IN A COMPREHENSIVE CANCER
CENTER. Karen Jones, RN, MS, CPHQ, Shawn Elliott, RNC, MSN, CNS, and Beverly
Nelson, RN, MS, University of Texas M.D. Anderson Cancer Center, Houston,
TX.
The management of cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) is challenging in
a comprehensive cancer center. Most patients who arrest are experiencing
end-stage disease and multi-system failure. Therefore, post-code survival
is generally poor. Even so, MDACC is committed to continuously improving
CPR services.
In 1999, anecdotal reports suggested possible problems related to timeliness
of code blue team response. At the same time, JCAHO published new standards
requiring effective CPR services and outcome measurements.
A multidisciplinary team was formed whose first accomplishment was to
map the code blue process in order to identify problematic areas. The
document revealed process steps, participating disciplines, functions
with unclear assignment of responsibility, and delays in the process.
The JCAHO standards and process map were used to develop an aim statement
and establish priorities.
The MDACC outcome and process measures developed by the multidisciplinary
team were derived from the “In-Hospital ‘Utstein Style’”
guidelines recommended by the American Heart Association (AHA). The key
measures led to the development of data collection tools, specifically,
the Code Blue Documentation form, the CPR QI Data Collection Tool, and
the Post-Code Blue Evaluation survey. The first two instruments provided
objective data and the latter tool provided qualitative information about
the code.
We have experienced numerous improvements to date. The response processes
have been expedited using new pagers and an improved paging system. Code
team membership was expanded to include the police to direct the responders,
a chaplain to support the family, and a phlebotomist to hand carry specimens
for immediate processing. All crash carts were replaced and contents were
updated to meet standards. An orientation program for the code team was
developed. We established our status as an AHA community CPR training
center to increase our ACLS and PALS certified personnel. Finally, AEDs
have been placed throughout the institution in non-patient care areas.
Our quarterly data reveal that our post-CPR survival rate remains stable,
the response time appears to have improved, and implementing ACLS guidelines
is more consistent. Following the dissemination of outcome information,
the number of post-code DNR designations increased to ninety-one percent
(91%).
3
EVALUATION OF LEADERSHIP STRATEGIES UTILIZED WHEN COMBINING TWO POPULATIONS
OF CRITICAL CANCER PATIENTS. Laura Espinosa, RN, MSN, CS, and Cynthia
Segal, RN, MSN, CNOR, University of Texas M.D. Anderson Cancer Center,
Houston, TX.
In December of 1999, the combination of two distinct cancer patient populations
in the critical care units (CCU) of The University of Texas M.D. Anderson
Cancer Center (MDA) required special attention and leadership skills.
Historically, the surgical intensive care (SICU) and medical surgical
care (MICU) units were managed and located on separate floors. As MDA
embarked on the utilization of a group of critical care physicians for
medical management of the 42-bed CCU, the challenge for cancer nurses
was to unify and enlist a true sense of teamwork among these very clinically
different and once separate services. Using Deming’s theory of teamwork
as a conceptual framework for the combination of these two units, unique
management skills balanced the staff’s strengths and weaknesses.
Initially, the name was changed from SICU and MICU to critical care unit
(CCU). A nurse manager was hired to lead the unification of the units.
With her goal of providing 24-hour management leadership, the single assistant
nurse manager (ANM) position was increased by three, while clinical expertise
was supported with two clinical nurse specialists (CNS). Agency nurse
utilization was eliminated through aggressive hiring to meet core staff
levels. Professional teambuilding consultants were enlisted to create
a shared vision and mission for the CCU. Subsequent teambuilding events
were directed toward establishing common rules and a mutual language to
gain a collective CCU ownership and pride.
The impact of two years of teamwork resulted in a significant reduction
of personnel turnover rates in the CCU. The 1999 CCU separation rate reduced
from 16.6% to the 12.5% in 2000.
Moreover, the CCU internal personnel transfer rates decreased from 17.7%
in 1999 to 8.9% in 2000. Total personnel cost was decreased by $95.00
per patient day. Additionally, the average variable cost per patient day
has decreased by $90.00 per patient day.
A shared vision, common patient goal, teamwork, and collaboration created
a successful environment in which to care for the critically ill cancer
patient.
4
UTILIZING JCAHO STANDARDS TO ACHIEVE PAIN MANAGEMENT. Kristin Feldkamp,
BSN, RN, and Barbara Schroeder, MS, RN, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN.
Despite the availability of highly effective therapies for pain, research
suggests that 42% of cancer patients do not receive adequate treatment
of their pain. Their fear of pain is so great that 69% report they would
consider suicide if their pain reached unacceptable levels. Although patients
are highly motivated to seek out effective pain management, personal barriers
often hinder them. After evaluating the current practice on a large medical
center’s oncology unit, it was found that patients using opioids
often fear possible addiction, side effects, and appearing “weak”
or “bothersome” when asking for pain medications. Though nursing
staff verbally reassured patients and families about misconceptions and
concerns, no written pain education materials were consistently provided.
To address these concerns, a two-goal project was formulated.
To enhance effective pain management communication between nurses and
patients, an educational card was developed. The key components of this
card, taken directly from the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare
Organization’s 2001 pain standards, explains the rights and responsibilities
of the patient concerning pain management and includes the numeric, facial,
and color pain scales. These pain scales were also laminated and placed
in each patient’s room.
To assist in providing a more comprehensive educational resource, Pain
Control, A Guide for People with Cancer and their Families was used to
address barriers patients have to taking pain medication and non-drug
therapies for pain management.
To evaluate outcomes, a pre-pilot audit was done on 30 charts to assess
patient pain scale ratings on admission and discharge and nursing interventions.
During the pilot, nearly 70% of nurses stated that the materials led to
further discussion with their patients. They also felt patients were more
willing and able to rate their pain due to the posting of the pain scales.
A post implementation chart audit revealed increased utilization of educational
resources and a decrease in patient-reported pain levels.
The importance of controlling cancer pain merits high priority. This project
has demonstrated that patient education may decrease patient barriers,
resulting in pain being more effectively treated.
This produces a higher quality of life for each patient.
5
HEALING TOUCH AND REIKI: INDEPENDENT NURSING FUNCTIONS TO SUPPORT CANCER
PATIENTS. Cynthia A. Teague, RN, BSN, CPON, University of Texas M.D. Anderson
Cancer Center, Houston, TX.
Touch therapies have been used for centuries to relax patients and promote
healing. Therapeutic touch, from which many aspects of Healing Touch are
derived, was formally introduced into nursing in the early 70’s
by Delores Kreiger. She developed a research base, and taught nurses to
use therapeutic touch to balance the body’s energy field and restore
harmony, allowing the patient to heal.
Reiki (ray-kee) is an ancient Japanese form of energy healing with the
primary purpose of restoring the balance in the body to promote the individual’s
ability to heal. Both of these techniques are considered forms of energy
healing. Theoretical work in energy healing was pioneered in nursing by
Martha Rogers who described the body as an energy field in interaction
with other energy fields and the global energy field. Although these therapies
are ancient, the research base for them is still in its infancy. Benor
(1993) reviewed 155 studies on energy healing and concluded that energy
healing can be an effective treatment, especially for immune compromised
conditions.
Healing touch has traditionally been a primarily nurse-initiated intervention
and Reiki is becoming almost as popular among nurses who espouse energy
healing. These therapies have been used with patients of all ages, including
children, with a minimum effect of calming the patients, decreasing pulse
rate, and increasing skin temperature. The stress reduction effect has
obvious implications for cancer patients who experience stress-provoking
events from diagnosis through the treatment and outcomes period. Of these
therapies, healing touch and Reiki have the greatest potential as noninvasive
techniques to be used on a regular basis by the clinical nurses as they
provide daily care to the patient. This presentation will include an overview
of Reiki and Healing Touch including the underlying tenets, available
research to support its use, the techniques involved, and future directions.
6
REIKI TREATMENTS FOR PEOPLE LIVING WITH CANCER. Larraine M. Bossi, RN,
MS, CS, Children’s Hospital, Boston, MA; Susan DeCristofaro, RN,
MS, OCN®, and Mary Jane Ott, RN, MN, MEd, CS, Dana-Farber Cancer Institute,
Boston, MA.
Background: Reiki is a healing method that uses “laying on of
hands” in a precise method that connects the universal energy with
the body’s innate power to heal. The goal of a Reiki treatment is
to restore the harmonious balance of mind, body, and spirit. Reiki has
been used with both adult and pediatric populations to achieve improved
quality of life. Published reports describe the benefits of Reiki, including
improvement in post-surgery pain.
Program: Reiki treatments have been integrated into the care of cancer
patients at our institution, an NCI-designated comprehensive cancer center.
Patients, who receive both standard and experimental cancer therapies,
are generally self-referred for the Reiki and pay out-of-pocket. Attending
physicians are notified about the scheduled treatments, allowing for dialogue
with the Reiki practitioner. The treatment sessions take place in private
clinic rooms and last 45–60 minutes, which differ from shorter,
more impromptu Reiki treatments that may be offered during routine nursing
care. Often these treatments are scheduled just before or after scheduled
radiation therapy, chemotherapy, or a procedure. Description of the Reiki
treatments, patient symptoms, and functional level are documented in the
medical record.
Evaluation: Between November 2000 and July 2001, 82+ Reiki sessions were
provided. Women utilized this service more than men (93% versus 7%), and
most referrals (over 80%) were for symptom management. There were no reported
side effects from any Reiki treatments. However there were many benefits
that were voiced and documented: decreased pain and increased mobility
with peripheral neuropathy; improved sleep patterns; and decreased anxiety
about treatment options, helping with decision-making. Patients reported
immediate results as well as some changes noticed hours after treatment.
A formalized evaluation tool was implemented in August 2001 to provide
additional descriptive data about the Reiki treatments.
Discussion: Reiki is safe and appears to provide symptom relief in many
cancer patients. Many cancer patients are seeking out this alternative
treatment that can be easily learned by oncology nurses and readily integrated
into their practice. Reiki is another tool for oncology nurses to use
as they care for and comfort cancer patients.
7
PATH TO HEALING WITH CANCER: AN INNOVATIVE SUPPORTIVE GROUP USING EXPRESSIVE
AND CREATIVE THERAPIES, MEDITATION, AND MASSAGE. Martha W. Healey, RN,
MSN, FNP, Susan Bauer-Wu, DNSc, RN, Dana-Farber Cancer Institute, Boston,
MA; and Elana Rosenbaum, MS, MSW, LICSW, University of Massachusetts Medical
School, Worcester, MA.
Background: Many cancer survivors want to learn new tools to enhance
their recovery and live well beyond cancer. Studies have documented the
benefits of support groups, mind-body techniques, massage, and expressive
therapies. Traditionally these different interventions have been offered
separately to patients, rather than integrating them within one therapeutic
format. Recognizing the value of each of these interventions, coupled
by patients’ requests for “more than a typical support group,”
an innovative “supportive” group, Path to Healing With Cancer
(PHWC), was created.
Intervention: PHWC is a monthly group for persons with cancer. Two healthcare
professionals facilitate the group; one, an advanced practice oncology
nurse with training and experience in expressive therapies and meditation,
the other, a clinical social worker who is also a cancer survivor and
meditation instructor. The group, held at Hope Lodge, an American Cancer
Society “home-away from home” for cancer patients, takes place
from 6–9 pm. Cancer patients in the community as well as those at
Hope Lodge attend. The evening combines guided meditation, gentle body
movement, art, writing, and dialogue. Each session has a theme, usually
consistent with the seasons (i.e., “planting our seeds and blossoming”).
After two hours, massage, Reiki, and reflexology are offered, without
charge, by certified professionals who volunteer their services. The evening
ends with informal sharing and light refreshments.
Evaluation: Since its inception in December 1999, the group has grown
with approximately 12 participants each month, many coming since its inception.
Some participants travel over an hour to attend this group. Although formal
evaluations have not been conducted, consistent participation and verbal
feedback are indicative of its benefits: “This is the one thing
I do for myself each month that I never want to miss.” “This
group gives me strength and peace of mind more than any other group I’ve
attended.”
Interpretation: Success of this innovative group is evident. Cancer patients
are seeking group interventions that incorporate various integrative therapies
to enhance their recovery. PHWC is a unique group and provides a model
for oncology nurses and other professionals to refer or offer such programs
to complement the care of their cancer patients.
8
OUTCOMES OF A SLEEP INTERVENTION FOLLOWING ADJUVANT CHEMOTHERAPY. Ann
M. Berger, PhD, RN, AOCN®, University of Nebraska College of Nursing,
Omaha, NE; Patti Higginbotham, MS, RN, OCN®, Wings of Hope Cancer
Center, Council Bluffs, IA; Susanna VonEssen, MD, MPH, UNMC-Pulmonary,
Omaha, NE; Brett Kuhn, PhD, UNMC-MMI, Omaha, NE; Barbara Piper, DNS, RN,
AOCN®, FAAN, UNMC-CON, Omaha, NE; and Sangeeta Agrawal, MSc, UNMC-CON,
Omaha, NE.
Significance: Fatigue and difficulty sleeping are frequent and distressing
symptoms in women during and following adjuvant breast cancer chemotherapy
(ABCC). Poor sleep adversely affects daytime activity and mood and leads
to more intense and distressing symptom clusters. Interventions need to
be tested to modify sleep and fatigue and promote recovery following ABCC.
Problem and Purpose: There is a high prevalence of fatigue and insomnia
in women treated with ABCC. This study examined the outcomes of a sleep
intervention consisting of sleep hygiene counseling, relaxation therapy,
sleep curtailment, and stimulus control methods following ABCC.
Theoretical Framework: Components of Piper’s Integrated Fatigue
Model (innate host factors, patterns of sleep/wake, activity/exercise).
Methods: A prospective, repeated measures design was used for this feasibility
study developed by a multi-disciplinary team. Caucasian women (N = 21)
had surgery for stage I or II breast cancer followed by adriamycin-based
chemotherapy (eight also had Taxol, 10 had radiation, 18 were taking Tamoxifen).
They had no unstable co-morbidities, they were between the ages of 43–66
(X = 55.3), most of them had some post-secondary education, and most were
married and employed. Reliable and valid instruments were used: Daily
Diary, Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI), wrist actigraphs, and Piper
Fatigue Scale (PFS). An Individual Sleep Promotion Plan (ISPP) was negotiated
by the researcher and each woman at 30, 60, and 90 days after the last
chemotherapy dose, and reinforced one week later. Follow-up occurred one
year after the first treatment.
Data Analysis: Epi-Info, Action 3, and SPSS data programs.
Findings/Implications: Latency, time wake after sleep onset (WASO), sleep
efficiency, total rest and feelings upon awakening data (diary & PSQI)
demonstrated wide ranges, with means within normal limits for all except
WASO. Actigraphic measures of mean activity (mesor and amplitude) slowly
and steadily returned to normal by one year. Actigraphic measures revealed
frequent (10–11) awakenings/night at early measures and less frequent
(8.8) at one year. Fatigue (PFS) ranged from 3.2–3.4 early, and
was down to 2.87 at one year. The intervention assisted in promoting activity,
obtaining quality sleep, and keeping fatigue levels mild. Reductions in
the time WASO are needed and will be tested using an experimental design
and a larger sample.
9
NURSES CARING FOR THE SPIRIT: CANCER PATIENT AND FAMILY CAREGIVER EXPECTATIONS.
Elizabeth Johnston Taylor, PhD, RN, Loma Linda University School of Nursing,
Loma Linda, CA.
Oncology nurses are increasingly expected to provide spiritual care to
their clients. Research findings underscore the need for nurturing client
spiritual health, especially for cancer care recipients. Yet scanty and
outdated evidence exists to document what spiritual care giving cancer
patients and their family members expect from nurses. Understanding client
perceptions can help oncology nurses to inoffensively and effectively
provide spiritual care. One purpose of this cross-sectional, descriptive,
qualitative study was to describe, from the perspective of patients and
family caregivers, what are their expectations of nurses regarding having
spiritual needs addressed. Conceptually, this investigation was influenced
by several scholars (especially, Reed, Frankl, and Travelbee) who have
theorized about how and why spirituality is important when living with
a health challenge, and Clinebell who identified categories of spiritual
need. Methods for collecting data included conducting audio-tape-recorded
semi-structured interviews with 27 white or black cancer patients and
family caregivers. Concurrent data analysis of transcribed interviews
followed Miles and Huberman’s approach to content analysis which
includes data reduction (coding), data display (categorizing themes after
constant comparative analysis), and verification. Results suggest a continuum
of client responses regarding nurses providing spiritual care. This continuum
was anchored by those who expressed open receptivity to nurses caring
overtly for their spiritual health and by others who were adamant that
a nurse should not meddle with client spiritual needs. Negative responses
to nurses providing spiritual care often reflected confusion about any
difference between spirituality and religiosity (e.g., informants frequently
equated spiritual care with nurses initiating religious conversation or
rituals). Findings also include nursing approaches identified by informants
that would “boost the spirit,” as well as those that informants
perceived would not be helpful or even harmful. These results offer client
perceptions about the role and practices of nurses regarding spiritual
care. With these findings, nurses can be sensitive and informed while
offering spiritual care. Nursing spiritual assessments, indeed, may need
to include an assessment of client perceptions about nurses providing
spiritual care. Client perceptions of what is spiritual care may need
to be reshaped prior to any overt spiritual assessment or care activities.
(Funded by the Oncology Nursing Foundation/Glaxo Wellcome Oncology Small
Research Grant.)
10
WHY HAVEN’T YOU GONE BACK? PREDICTORS OF NOT RETURNING FOR DIAGNOSTIC
FOLLOW-UP AFTER AN ABNORMAL MAMMOGRAM. Alexis Bakos, PhD, MPH, RN, C,
National Cancer Institute, Bethesda, MD.
Mammography is one of the most important means of breast cancer screening.
It is estimated that as many as 60% of the women who have an abnormal
mammogram do not return for further medical evaluation. The purpose of
this study was to determine factors related to a woman’s decision
to obtain appropriate diagnostic follow-up after an abnormal screening
mammogram. Cox’s Interaction Model of Client Health Behavior was
used as a conceptual framework to identify key predictor variables that
are elements of client singularity and client-professional interaction.
The study used a retrospective design. A convenience sample of 243 women
with abnormal mammograms from two urban university medical centers was
invited to participate in the study. The study sample included 75 women.
Forty-four women who returned for diagnostic follow-up and 31 women who
had not returned were interviewed using a telephone survey method to determine
which variables predicted follow-up and most accurately classified women
into either category. The ages of the women ranged from 29–85 years
with a mean age of 52 (SD = 11) and 89% of the women were African American.
A majority of women (69%) had insurance coverage for their mammogram.
Telephone interviews assessed demographic variables (including social
influences, previous healthcare experience, and environmental resources),
cancer fatalism (Powe Fatalism Inventory, alpha = .88), anxiety (Trait
Anxiety Inventory, alpha = .91), depression (Beck Depression Inventory,
alpha = unstable estimate), perceived cancer screening experience (Screening
Satisfaction Scale, alpha = .76), and mammography induced pain (Painometer-Words,
internal consistency reliability = n/a). Data were analyzed using chi-square,
ANOVA, and logistic regression to aid in prediction. The results suggest
that women who had greater cancer fatalism and depression, experienced
less mammography induced pain, were age 50 years or younger, and had less
perceived breast cancer risk, had significantly greater odds of not returning
for diagnostic follow-up (model chi-square = 47.94, df = 10, p = .000).
The logistic regression model correctly classified 81% of the women on
the outcome variable. The findings can be used by nurses in cancer detection
to increase awareness of those at risk for not returning and test suggested
intervention strategies to improve diagnostic follow-up after an abnormal
screening mammogram.
11
PHYSICAL AND PSYCHOLOGICAL HEALTH OUTCOMES IN PATIENTS WITH CANCER PARTICIPATING
IN A STRUCTURED EXERCISE PROGRAM. Stacey Young-McCaughan, RN, PhD, AOCN®,
U.S. Army Medical Research & Materiel Command, Fort Detrick, MD; Stacey
Dramiga, MA, Brooke Army Medical Center, San Antonio, TX; Linda Yoder,
RN, MBA, PhD, AOCN®, Walter Reed Army Medical Center, Washington,
DC; John Caton, Jr., MD, Sonya Huizar, BS, Geneva Foundation, San Antonio,
TX; and Mary Mays, PhD, Eagle Creek Research Services.
Problem & Purpose: Recent research studies that have investigated
exercise rehabilitation in patients with cancer have documented dramatic
improvements in physiological and psychological functioning. The purpose
of this study was to investigate the capability of an exercise program
patterned after a phase II cardiac rehabilitation program to improve selected
physiological and psychological parameters of health in patients with
cancer.
Theoretical Framework: The Roy Adaptation Model was the framework used
for this study.
Methods: This prospective, repeated measures study enrolled 62 patients
diagnosed with cancer within the previous two years into a structured
exercise program patterned after a phase II cardiac rehabilitation program.
Subjects met two days each week for 12 weeks for exercise and education.
The dependent study variables were changed over time in exercise tolerance
as measured with a graded exercise test, activity and rest patterns as
measured with a wrist actigraph, and quality of life as measured with
the CARES-SF.
Data Analysis: Descriptive statistics and repeated-measures analysis of
variance were used to analyze the data.
Findings: Half of the participants were male and half female. Subjects
were predominantly Caucasian, married, and well-educated, with almost
three-quarters of the sample having college preparation. Ages of participants
ranged from 24–83 (mean = 59). Participants had a wide range of
cancer diagnoses. Most subjects had early stage I or II disease. Seventeen
subjects were undergoing treatment when they were enrolled into the study.
More than half of the subjects exercised prior to their cancer diagnosis,
however, fewer than half of these patients were able to resume an exercise
routine following their cancer diagnosis. Forty-six subjects were able
to complete the 12-week exercise protocol. Significant improvements were
observed over time in exercise tolerance and quality of life (p < .05).
Completed analyses will include an examination of sleep indices.
Implications: These findings indicate that patients with various types
and stages of cancer can safely exercise using a cardiac rehabilitation
model and that significant improvements in exercise tolerance and quality
of life can be realized in this patient population.
(Funded by the Department of Defense TriService Nursing Research Program
N98-051.)
12
CARING FOR THE DYING: DEVELOPING NEW NURSES TO FACE THE CHALLENGE. Caryl
Fulcher, MSN, RN, CS, and Sheree Dunn, RN, Clinical Nurse IV, Duke University
Health Systems, Durham, NC.
One of the experiences most feared by new nurses is that of caring for
dying patients and their families. Often their nursing school experience
has been limited in this area, and their curriculum content may have been
minimal as well. Because death is so feared by many in our society, and
because it is associated with so many personal, cultural, and spiritual
beliefs, many new nurses have not taken the opportunity to reflect on
their own loss history and its impact on their developing philosophy.
The purpose of this project is to assist new oncology nurses to develop
comfort and skills necessary to provide sensitive end-of-life care.
In an attempt to assess the perceptions, the new graduate nurse brings
to clinical practice a 12-item questionnaire entitled, “How Do I
Really Feel About the Person Who Is Dying?” which was completed
during the orientation period by the eleven graduate nurses enrolled in
an oncology nurse internship program. The responses from the questionnaire
guide the assigned advanced practice nurse mentors to discuss fears or
biases and “process” actual clinical experiences with patients
and families to create a helpful learning experience. In addition to this
nurse-mentor discussion, didactic content on grief and loss is presented.
It is well known that nurses who work closely with dying patients are
at high risk for grief reactions and burnout, so resources available to
support the nurse are specifically identified. As a means of evaluation,
the questionnaire will be repeated after the nurse has practiced for eight
months to see if the concerns expressed have changed to indicate more
comfort with end-of-life care. Remaining gaps can then be addressed in
an effort to aid nurse development and also retention.
13
THE LONG AND WINDING ROAD OF THE ADVANCED PRACTICE NURSE (APN): INTEGRATING
PALLIATIVE CARE EARLY IN CANCER TREATMENT. Rose Anne Indelicato, RN, MSN,
CS, ANP, OCN®, Jean Adelhardt, RN, MA, Candace Coggins, CARN, MS,
MA, NP, and Jackie Levin, RN, MS, HNC, CHTP, Beth Israel Medical Center,
New York, NY.
Topic: Palliative care can provide physical, psychological, and spiritual
support for patients and caregivers at every stage of cancer treatment.
At present, however, the need for palliative care often goes unnoticed
until patients become terminally ill. This presentation will highlight
how one facility has incorporated the unique talents of a group of advanced
practice nurses (APNs) in the provision of comprehensive palliative care
across many clinical settings and stages of disease.
Rationale: The ONS position paper asserts that “APNs are a vital
component of the healthcare team that provides care to patients with cancer,
and the role is essential to providing cost-effective, quality care for
diverse populations.”
Interventions: We will describe the multi-faceted roles of APNs in a department
of pain medicine and palliative care (DPMPC) at a 710-bed lower Manhattan
hospital with a diverse patient population. In addition to education and
research, APN clinical activities include DPMPC clinic sessions (NP and
CNS), outpatient cancer and fatigue centers, telephone-based case management,
and providing continuity of care between active cancer treatment and end-of-life
care through hospice. We will highlight the APN in the provision of palliative
care early in the course of disease by illustrating areas of clinician
expertise in pain and symptom management, home care, hospice, psychiatric
nursing, chemical dependency, and complementary/alternative medicine (CAM)
therapies. We will discuss barriers faced in providing palliative care
such as reimbursement issues, provider limited expertise in symptom management,
and lack of comfort in discussing advance directives and goal of care;
patient/caregiver equating palliative care with “suboptimal”
care; the inconsistencies between cultural/religious beliefs and the ability
to offer quality symptom control. Through case presentations, we will
show the impact that APNs can have on implementing early palliative care.
Interpretation/Discussion: APNs are poised to bring palliative care into
patient management early in the cancer trajectory. Patients and caregivers
can be better served if oncology nurses communicate, from the start, that
palliative care, with its focus on quality of life, is as essential to
ongoing patient care as is treatment for the underlying disease.
14
LIVING WITH DYING: SPIRITUALITY AT THE END OF LIFE. Pamela Shockey Stephenson,
RN, MSN, CS, OCN®, CHPN, Forum Health Cancer Care Center, Warren,
OH.
Little is known about the experience of spirituality in the lives of
hospice patients despite the fact that it is during the end of life that
spiritual development is thought to be of central concern to patients.
Nurses report feeling unprepared to address spiritual needs because they
lack an understanding of the meaning of spirituality in the lives of hospice
patients (Taylor, Highfield, & Amenta, 1999).
This study used interpretive phenomenology to explore the experience of
spirituality from the perspective of the hospice patient (Benner, 1994).
Unstructured, in-depth interviews, during which participants were asked
to describe the experience of spirituality in their lives were conducted
with six hospice patients. A four-member interpretive team analyzed the
data using the strategies outlined by Diekelmann, Allen, and Tanner (1989).
All the participants shared stories about spirituality and dying that
were consistent with their views about spirituality throughout their lives.
They did not demonstrate any significant spiritual transformations when
they learned they were dying.
Two sub-themes emerged from the data which indicated what issues were
most important to the participants as death approached. The first sub-theme
of “who is in charge” reflected the participants’ consistency
regarding who was in charge of their life, illness, and dying, be it themselves
and/or God. The second sub-theme of “connecting and disconnecting”
revealed the importance of joining with either other humans and/or God
throughout life and in death.
The participants’ expectation of nurses was not to participate in
spiritual tasks or to engage in in-depth spiritual dialogue, but to reinforce
their sense of spirituality, to display the “good” qualities
of humankind. These findings suggest that nurses should respect the patients
struggle to determine who is in charge and, rather than perform “spiritual
tasks,” and provide a meaningful connection to the dying patient.
15
TEACHING END-OF-LIFE: MULTIMEDIA TOOLKIT FOR NURSING. Diana J. Wilkie,
PhD, RN, FAAN, University of Washington, Seattle, WA; M. Kay M. Judge,
EdD, RN, University of Washington and Nursing Consult, LTD., Seattle,
WA; and Stuart J. Farber, MD, University of Washington, Seattle, WA.
Most nursing programs lack sufficient palliative care content meaning
that nursing students may have insufficient knowledge to provide high-quality
care for people facing death. A solution to this problem is for a team
of interdisciplinary, end-of-life experts to create tools that can be
used by nurse educators in academic and clinical settings. TNEEL (Tool-Kit
for Nursing Excellence at End-of-Life Transition) provides nurse educators
with such a solution. TNEEL, a CD-ROM-based program, is an easy-to-access,
user-friendly package of tools to teach palliative care. Multiple teaching
strategies are included in this evidence-based, multimedia toolkit of
instructional aids. Educators can use these tools to engage students in
meaningful learning activities. TNEEL includes six core end-of-life care
topics: Comfort goals and preferences including assessment and management
of pain and other symptoms; ethical and legal decision-making; connections
(communications and relationships supporting patient and family-centered
care); grief loss and bereavement; well-being (hope, suffering, complementary
comfort therapies, spiritual and psychosocial needs); and impact (the
impact of end-of-life care on patients, families, and society). Within
each of these topics, the TNEEL teaching portfolio includes: student learning
objectives; pre- and post-assessment items; common myths and misconceptions,
definitions of terms; teaching materials (lecture outlines and text materials);
PowerPoint™ slides with speaker/instructor notes using multimedia
(video, audio, graphics) to illustrate learning activities; case studies
for problem-based learning; learning activities that promote critical
thinking; and resources (references, bibliographies, web resources, movies,
books, arts). Core concepts are woven throughout TNEEL including individual
and cultural diversity, family centered care across the lifespan, interdisciplinary
collaborative care, settings and systems of care, and values and attitudes.
TNEEL gives nurse educators access to electronic teaching aides that will
meet their needs and preferences. With future advances such as hand-held
and bedside computers, TNEEL could mentor students in effective end-of-life
care when and where they need it most—with vulnerable individuals
and families facing end-of-life transitions. TNEEL will be delivered,
free of charge, to every academic nursing program and to 1,000 clinical
agencies as a gift from the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. This presentation
will orient nurses to TNEEL’s innovations and benefits.
16
DEVELOPMENT OF A BREAST CANCER RISK ASSESSMENT PROGRAM. Laurel Snyder,
RN, MS, National Naval Medical Center, Bethesda, MD; Lynda L. Lahl, RN,
MS, National Cancer Institute, Bethesda, MD; Michele Nehrebecky, RN, CRNP,
National Cancer Institute, Bethesda, MD; Peter Soballe, MC, USN, U.S.
Navy, Bethesda, MD; and Pamela Klein, MD, Genentech, Inc., South San Francisco,
CA.
Advances in the chemoprevention of breast cancer over the last five years
have given women at high risk management options for the first time. Results
from the Breast Cancer Prevention Trial (BCPT) clearly demonstrated that
tamoxifen, a selective estrogen receptor modulator (SERM), could reduce
breast cancer by 50%. The FDA approval of tamoxifen in 1997 for use in
prevention challenged providers to identify women who might benefit from
tamoxifen, as well as those women in which the risks outweigh the benefits.
The Breast Care Center at the National Naval Medical Center is a multidisciplinary
facility jointly run by the National Cancer Institute and the Navy. In
response to the numerous requests for prevention information after the
results of the BCPT were released, a breast cancer education session and
risk assessment program was developed. The intention was to provide patients
with general information about breast cancer, risk assessment, and prevention.
It was anticipated that there would be an increased need within the clinic
for healthcare providers to discuss options available to women not only
at increased risk for breast cancer, but for those individuals looking
for overall breast cancer prevention information. There was a concern
that many of the providers would be unable to adequately discuss this
information with the patients in both a timely and efficient manner.
Since the implementation of the bi-monthly education program in March
1999, the session has effectively provided baseline information on breast
cancer, risks, prevention options, clinical trials, and information regarding
their personal risk of breast cancer. This has allowed more appropriate
triage for the high-risk patients needing further consultation from those
patients who just required general information. Patients have provided
both verbal and written satisfaction with the information provided in
the class and have thus become active participants in their health care.
In addition, this baseline information allows for a more focused and time
efficient consultation with a provider. This experience suggests that
group education may be a viable and acceptable way to bring new advances
in breast cancer prevention to large groups of women and their significant
others.
17
COLON CANCER GET CHECKED PROGRAM: AWARENESS TO ACTION PROGRAM. Sandra
J. Donnelly, RN, OCN®, Nora Katurakes, RN, MSN, OCN®, and Charlene
Marinelli, BSN, OCN®, Christiana Care Health Services, Wilmington,
DE.
Colon cancer is the third most common malignancy and the second leading
cause of cancer mortality in the United States. The American Cancer Society
(ACS) has estimated 130,200 new cases of colon cancer and 56,300 deaths
for the year 2001. Delaware is ranked fifth in the nation for colon deaths.
ACS reports that only 17.9% of Delaware men and 24.6% of Delaware women
have had a recent fecal occult blood test (FOBT). Annual screening with
FOBT can result in a 15%–33% reduction in mortality as reported
in clinical trials.
In October 2000, the Christiana Care Cancer Outreach Program (CCCOP) implemented
the Colon Cancer: Get Checked Program that includes information about
risk factors, prevention guidelines and screening. The program goal is
to screen 250 men and women who are age 50 years and older by March 2002.
CCCOP message is “Take Four Easy Steps for a Colon Check”:
1) Learn about it, 2) Decide to get tested, 3) Get a test kit, and 4)
Talk about the results. An 11-item tool is used to determine average or
high-risk and eligibility for a FOBT kit. A group of 15 men, mostly African-American
over the age of 50, piloted this program including review of the promotional
flyer, risk assessment tool, and kit instructions. Revisions were made
based on the findings. An outreach worker recruited participants at 36
community educational events including churches, civic associations, worksites,
and health fairs.
Preliminary results as of August 2001 show 53 requested to participate.
Three were found to be high-risk and were referred to their physician
to discuss a screening plan. Twenty-eight of 50 (average risk) consented
to receive kits for testing, and nine have been returned to CCCOP for
processing. All returned were negative. A reminder letter was issued to
all participants who did not return kits as scheduled. No additional contact
was made after this step. The next steps include promoting the program
on the Christiana Care Health System web site, analyzing the data from
late- and regional-stage disease to help develop a specific outreach plan,
and surveying recent participants for feedback about the program’s
components.
18
THE MAP OF DECISIONS TO DELAY BREAST SYMPTOM EVALUATION. Noreen C. Facione,
RN, PhD, University of California, San Francisco, CA; and Peter Facione,
PhD, Santa Clara University, Santa Clara, CA.
Problem and Purpose: Early diagnosis and treatment of breast cancer requires
women to appraise their self-discovered symptoms as posing the threat
of breast cancer and to decide to seek immediate evaluation from a provider.
Research has shown that this appraisal and decision process is a reflective
judgment process influenced by social and psychological variables.
Theory: This cognitive decision-making process results in a confidence
that one is making good judgments about cancer risk. However, the symptom
appraisal and decision process itself has not been adequately studied.
Cognitive theory grounds this study of women currently experiencing breast
symptoms.
Methods: In depth interviews were conducted in the homes of 25 symptomatic
women recruited in a community-based study of breast health behavior.
The sample women were Latino (36%), Black (16%), and White (48%). They
ranged in age from 24–72 years (mean = 40.0 years, sd = 16.5), and
varied across income levels.
Analysis: This study used two analytical methods (content and argument
analysis) to analyze the content and the reasoning process in these interviews.
Decision maps were then constructed to display the thinking processes
involved in each woman’s symptom appraisal and to display each woman’s
decision about whether or when to seek evaluation. The 25 decision maps
were then compared for similar reasoning patterns.
Findings and Implications for Practice: In five of the interviews, women
appraised their symptoms as cancer and sought immediate evaluation. In
seven of the other interviews, women attributed their symptoms to cancer
and yet were among the 10 (40%) of the women who decided to delay seeking
evaluation. The analyzed decision processes and analysis of the aptitudes
and knowledge used in these decisions explained women’s appraisal
as malignant or benign, and their subsequent decisions to delay, even
when they attributed the symptom to breast cancer. The findings suggest
new clinical approaches for counseling women about the risk of delaying
the evaluation of self-discovered breast symptoms and new media approaches
for early cancer detection.
19
A PROSPECTIVE STUDY OF PATIENT SENSATIONS AFTER BREAST CANCER SURGERY.
Roberta H. Baron, RN, MSN, AOCN®, Jane V. Fey, MPH, and Kimberly J.
Van Zee, MS, MD, Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center, New York, NY.
Topic: Many breast cancer patients describe distressing postoperative
sensations and question if these feelings are normal. This phenomenon
remains poorly understood. Few studies have evaluated sensations in patients
who had sentinel lymph node biopsy (SLNB) compared to axillary lymph node
dissection (ALND). Our study evaluated sensations over time and with different
surgical procedures.
Purpose: To evaluate prevalence, severity, and level of distress of sensations
at one week (baseline), 3, 6, and 12 months after breast cancer surgery.
Theoretical Framework: This study is based on the University of California
San Francisco Symptom Management Model in which careful symptom assessment
is a prerequisite for effective symptom management.
Methods: Patients completed the Breast Sensation Assessment Scale (BSAS),
an instrument developed by the investigators. The BSAS contains 18 descriptors
of breast/axilla sensations. Patients recorded each sensation as present
or absent, and if present, rated it on severity and level of distress.
The BSAS demonstrated good reliability and validity in our previous studies.
Data Analysis: Prevalence, severity, and distress of sensations in different
populations were compared using Fisher’s Exact Test.
Findings and Implications: 261 patients completed the BSAS at baseline,
3, 6, and 12 months. Surgery included SLNB + Breast Conservation (BCT)(53%),
SLNB + Total Mastectomy (TM)(13%), ALND + BCT(20%), and ALND + TM(14%).
At baseline, tenderness and soreness were the most prevalent in SLNB and
ALND. In SLNB, this remained constant at 3, 6, and 12 months. In ALND,
numbness and tightness became the most prevalent at 3, 6, and 12 months
and were significantly more severe and distressing (p < .05) when compared
to SLNB. Prevalence of phantom breast/nipple sensations in the TM population
remained fairly constant. Prevalence at baseline was 38%, 3 months 40%,
6 months 36%, and 12 months (38%). TM patients with tissue expander reconstruction
(TE) had significantly more aching and tingling at baseline (p < .05)
than those without TE. There was no significant difference in prevalence
of sensations at baseline in patients who had SLNB + TE compared to ALND
+ TE. Certain sensations remain prevalent, severe, and distressing even
one year after surgery. This information will help nurses better understand
patients’ experiences so they can provide more accurate education
before and after surgery.
20
A RANDOMIZED TRIAL OF EXERCISE FOR NEWLY DIAGNOSED PATIENTS RECEIVING
CHEMOTHERAPY: EFFECTS ON BONE DENSITY AND BODY COMPOSITION. Anna L. Schwartz,
PhD, FNP, Marjorie King, MS, C-FNP, Catherine Samson, MPH, Tracy Beil,
MS, and Jennifer Holub, MS, Oregon Health & Science University, Portland,
OR.
Problem: During chemotherapy, it is common to observe declines in functional
ability and muscle strength and increases in body weight. Chemotherapy,
particularly doxorubicin or methotrexate in combination with steroids,
increases the potential for significant physical decline and predispose
patients to osteoporosis. Exercise may be a means of minimizing these
negative effects and decreasing risks for long-term treatment-related
complications such as osteoporosis and weight gain.
Conceptual Framework: The hypokinetic theory forms the conceptual basis
for this study that examines the effects of exercise on bone health, body
composition, and functional ability.
Purpose: The purpose of this longitudinal, randomized, repeated measures
study was to examine the effects of exercise on functional ability, muscle
strength, bone density (BMD), and body composition in newly diagnosed
cancer patients beginning chemotherapy with doxorubicin or methotrexate
and a steroid.
Methods: 66 newly diagnosed cancer patients (5 males/61 females) beginning
chemotherapy regimens were randomized to aerobic exercise (AE) (N = 23),
resistance exercise (RE) (N = 22), or usual care control (CG) (N = 21).
Exercise subjects were instructed to follow a four-day/week home-based
program. All subjects returned for follow-up exercise testing at three-month
intervals and bone densitometry scanning (DEXA) of the L-spine and total
body at baseline and six months.
Data Analysis: Descriptive analyses and repeated measures analysis of
variance were use to examine differences between the groups over time.
Findings: Greater increases in functional ability were observed in the
AE (16%) than the RE (9%) or CG (8%). Muscle strength significantly increased
in the AE and RE group, and declined in CG (p < .05). The mean decrease
in BMD at the L-spine was 4.3% (SD = 4.6, range = -16.4 to 2.9). Significantly
less decline in L-spine BMD was observed in AE (-1.6%) compared to RE
(-5.3%) and CG (-5.9%) (p<.05, F=4.7). No significant changes in body
fat were observed between groups.
Implications: Findings support the idea that AE may reduce the bone-wasting
effects of chemotherapy and may assist in maintaining or improving body
composition, functional ability, and muscle strength during chemotherapy.
These outcomes may be critical to improving quality of life and reducing
risks for long-term treatment related side effects.
Funding: NIH R29 NR04945
21
CHEMOTHERAPY DOCUMENTATION FORMS: GUIDING PRACTICE AND ASSURING COMPLIANCE
WITH ONS GUIDELINES. Kathleen Beaudoin, RN, BSN, and Kristine Rossof,
RN, Rush-Presbyterian-St. Luke’s Medical Center, Chicago, IL.
Chemotherapy administration and documentation is an ongoing challenge
for hematology, oncology, and BMT nurses. Our institution utilizes a two-day
ONS certification workshop to update chemotherapy drug information and
practice for oncology nurses. The ONS encourages the implementation of
their guidelines to improve clinical performance and safe patient care.
One nurse’s concern for her own documentation practice led her to
develop a basic documentation tool, incorporating the guidelines of the
ONS teaching manual. The staff nurses were included with a poster presentation
and discussion on the use of the form. The nurse manager, clinical pharmacist,
and risk manager reviewed the form for input. The form was divided to
provide separate notations for initiation, completion, and continuous-infusion
chemotherapy. Despite the institution’s practice to house patients
receiving intensive, high-dose chemotherapy within the oncology units,
the situation does occur requiring nurses outside those units to administration
chemotherapy. The documentation tool was therefore evaluated for its usefulness
to guide the chemotherapy practice for non-certified nurses, incorporating
proper dosing, safety factors, side effects, and patient education. The
long-term proposed plan is to distribute the hospital-approved form as
part of the chemotherapy kit currently delivered to the nursing unit by
pharmacy, promoting consistency of practice hospital wide. The oncology
nursing staff immediately acknowledged the usefulness of such a form to
improve their individual practice. For the experienced nurse, the tool
serves as a reminder for practice and thorough documentation of care delivered.
It is an educational tool for the novice oncology nurse and provides for
safe chemotherapy administration to nurses administering chemotherapy
infrequently. The poster presentation will display the chemotherapy documentation
forms, explaining the content necessary on initiation, completion, and
for continuous infusion chemotherapy. It is anticipated that documentation
of practice will improve on and off the oncology units. This improvement
can be evaluated through staff written and verbal feedback and medical
record evaluation. The forms could be easily adapted for use in other
settings.
22
“ATAQ”ING NEUTROPENIA MANAGEMENT. Cathy Mazzone, RN, MS, OCN®,
National Institute on Aging, National Institutes of Health, Baltimore,
MD.
Concerns over delays in initiation of a broad-spectrum antibiotic with
first fever in the neutropenic cancer patient heightened when this institution
began to see an increase in the number of these patients as a result of
an increase in the leukemia population. A baseline assessment showed a
mean time to initiation of a broad-spectrum antibiotic was five hours,
five minutes. Lack of education among the nursing staff was one of several
factors identified as influencing this time.
Multiple entries of access to care also contributed. The goal, reached
by consensus with outside hematology and infectious disease experts, along
with the performance improvement committee, was that a broad-spectrum
antibiotic be hung within one hour from the time the fever is documented
(inpatient) or from the time the patient arrives at the hospital (outpatient).
Re-education of the oncology staff focused on neutropenia management,
ANC calculations, and sharing the one-hour goal. Emergency room nursing
staff was also included. Next, a first fever order set was developed for
use by oncologists. Finally, the performance improvement committee developed
business cards that were given to patients at the end of their cycle of
treatment that outlined their period of neutropenia, and provided instructions
to unfamiliar staff as to the importance of prompt treatment. Patients
were instructed to hand the card to the triage nurse in the emergency
room when they came with fever. Current performance, two years after the
initiative, is a mean time of one hour, twenty minutes to initiation of
a broad spectrum antibiotic, including those patients coming through the
emergency room. The poster will outline the specifics of the education
program, the order set, the business card to be used when visiting the
emergency room, along with trending the improvements as these initiatives
were implemented.
23
DEVELOPING A CONSISTENT, EVIDENCE-BASED APPROACH FOR G-CSF (FILGRASTIM)
ADMINISTRATION: IMPLEMENTING A QUALITY IMPROVEMENT PROCESS TO IMPROVE
NEUTROPENIA MANAGEMENT. Nancy L. Budzinski, RN, BSN, and Mary Fran Overcash,
RN, BSN, Joliet Oncology-Hematology Associates Ltd., Joliet, IL.
The purpose of this clinical practice project was to develop guidelines
for hematopoietic colony-stimulating factor (CSF) administration in order
to more consistently and effectively manage chemotherapy-induced neutropenia.
Joliet Oncology Hematology Associates is a six-physician community oncology
practice treating an average of 1,000 outpatients per month. Specialty
trained nurses administer chemotherapy and assume a primary role in toxicity
assessment and symptom management. Nurses identified that variations in
physician practice with respect to myeloid CSF administration resulted
in an inconsistent approach to neutropenia management. The nursing staff
used a quality improvement approach to address this clinical practice
issue. The assessment process began with a retrospective chart review
of chemotherapy administration for aggressive NHL (n = 15) and adjuvant
breast cancer (n = 20) patients. Data was collected regarding dose delays,
dose reductions, use of hematopoietic CSF, and incidence of febrile neutropenia.
Analysis of data revealed that neutropenia was one of the primary causes
for dose delays and reductions. Inconsistencies in CSF dosing and initiation
and duration of therapy were found. The quality improvement plan involved
developing a more consistent approach to the use of hematopoietic CSF
in the proactive management of neutropenia. Two members of the nursing
staff partnered with a physician to draft guidelines for growth factor
administration based upon the ASCO 2000 Update of Recommendations for
the Use of Hematopoietic Colony-Stimulating Factors. Guidelines addressed
the key components of CSF administration such as appropriate dosing by
weight, initiation and duration of therapy, frequency of laboratory monitoring,
management of bone pain, and patient selection criteria for primary and
secondary prophylactic administration. Guidelines were implemented in
August 2001 after presentation to all six physicians for input, consensus,
and approval. The nursing staff will conduct an ongoing evaluation of
adherence to guidelines through periodic chart audits. Outcomes selected
for monitoring include appropriateness of CSF dose, initiation and duration
of CSF therapy, frequency of laboratory monitoring, management of bone
pain, patient selection criteria, incidence of febrile neutropenia, and
neutropenia related dose delays and reductions. These guidelines have
further enhanced the nursing staff’s ability to provide autonomous,
evidence-based, proactive symptom management to minimize the impact of
neutropenia in their practice setting.
24
THE NATURE OF CHANGE: USING THE FUNCTIONAL PERFORMANCE INDEX (FPI) WITH
PATIENTS UNDERGOING CANCER TREATMENT. Lillian M. Nail, PhD, RN, FAAN,
Oregon Health & Science University, Portland, OR; Susan Beck, PhD,
APRN, FAAN, AOCN®, and Karen Lindau, MS, OT, University of Utah College
of Nursing, Salt Lake City, UT.
Although function is widely recognized as an important quality-of-life
outcome, there is little information about types of activities that are
compromised during cancer treatment. The purpose of this analysis was
to describe the nature of self-reported functional impairment in patients
beginning treatment with chemotherapy or radiation therapy and examine
changes in function over the first few weeks of treatment. This study
was guided by concepts suggested by self-regulation theory. An instrument
that contains 65 detailed activity items, the FPI, was used. The FPI was
developed as a measure of function for use with patients with COPD and
has demonstrated reliability and validity in COPD (Leidy, 1999). In order
to capture the nature of activity changes in cancer patients, 100 subjects
participating in an RCT of an energy conservation intervention completed
the FPI at the beginning of cancer treatment and several weeks later during
treatment. The typical subject was a middle-aged (M = 56.7 years), married
(74%), woman (87%) with breast cancer (79%).
At the beginning of treatment, 55 subjects ranked body care as the most
or second-most important area of function, followed by social interaction
(n = 42) and household maintenance (n = 32). As expected, few subjects
reported activities as causing much difficulty. Activities requiring large
muscle movement and stretching, like carrying groceries, painting, cleaning,
or golf presented challenges to a few (<10) subjects. Changes in function
over time were examined using paired t-tests computed on FPI subscale
scores from baseline to during treatment measures within the control group
(n = 54) only as the energy conservation intervention is expected to influence
activity in the experimental group. There was a trend (p = .053) for physical
activity to decline as treatment progressed. Recreational activity decreased
over time (p = .019), but there were no changes in self-reported body
care, household maintenance, and social interaction. The findings of these
analyses indicate that changes in function are in areas other than personal
care ADLs and suggest that measures of function in cancer patients need
to encompass recreational and physical activity as well as traditional
ADL items. Implications for measuring function, including gender-based
items, preference, and attributions will be discussed.
25
THE EFFECTS OF SYMPTOM UNCERTAINTY ON THE EMOTIONAL AND FUNCTIONAL OUTCOMES
OF RADIATION THERAPY FOR CANCER. Norma J. Christman, PhD, RN, FAAN, University
of Kentucky College of Nursing, Lexington, KY; Linda B. Cain, PhD, RN,
Sherill N. Cronin, PhD, RN, Bellarmine University, Louisville, KY; and
Donna J. Corley, MSN, Doctoral Candidate, Morehead State University, Morehead,
KY.
Uncertainty about health-related experiences may profoundly influence
patient outcomes. Much of what is presently known about illness uncertainty
is based on the use of measures developed from cognitive models of information
processing and stress and coping with statistically derived subscales.
Studying uncertainty about specific aspects of health-related experiences,
for example symptoms, might lead to new understandings and more specific
intervention strategies.
The effects of symptom uncertainty (SU) on emotional and functional outcomes
were examined in 76 persons having radiation therapy (RT) for gynecologic,
lung, or head/neck cancers. Most had stage II or less disease (63%), were
within one month of diagnosis (83%), and were white (92%), female (68%),
and married (61%). All were treated with curative intent.
SU was measured with 10 items either modified or drawn from Mishel’s
Uncertainty in Illness Scale. Internal consistency was .67. A non-significant
correlation (.15, p > .05) between body awareness and SU supports the
scale’s discriminate validity; correlations between SU and measures
of predictability (-.47, p < .0001) and understanding (-.27, p <
.05) support concurrent validity. SU, emotional and functional outcomes,
and number of symptoms were measured treatment week three, and two, and
four weeks after RT. Outcome indicators were the summed scores from the
Profile of Mood States anxiety, depression, and anger subscales, and from
linear analog items derived from the Sickness Impact Profile household
management and recreation/pastimes scales, plus a linear analog item measuring
time spent away from home. A measure of optimism, the Life Orientation
Test, also was obtained. The effects of SU on outcomes were examined with
hierarchical regression controlling for optimism and number of symptoms.
SU explained 15% (p < .001, b = .43), 5% (p < .05, b = .23), and
14% (p < .001, b = .38) of the variance in emotion treatment week three,
and two, and four weeks after treatment respectively. Symptom uncertainty
contributed to the explanation of functional outcome only two (6%, p <
.05, b = -.26) and four (6%, p < .05, b = -.26) weeks following treatment.
Incorporating specific information about typical symptom experiences into
symptom management strategies may lessen negative effects of SU.
Further study about uncertainty due to specific aspects of health-related
experiences also is needed.
26
FATIGUE AND PHYSICAL FUNCTIONING DURING BREAST CANCER TREATMENT. Victoria
Mock, DNSC, AOCN®, Johns Hopkins Cancer Center, Baltimore, MD; Ruth
McCorkle, PhD, FAAN, Yale University School of Nursing, New Haven, CT;
Mary E. Ropka, PhD, RN, FAAN, University of Virginia School of Medicine,
Charlottesville, VA; Mary Pickett, PhD, RN, University of Pennsylvania
School of Nursing, Philadelphia, PA; and Barbara Poniatowski, MS, RN,
C, AOCN®, Greater Baltimore Medical Center, Baltimore, MD.
Fatigue during cancer treatment often leads to decreases in activity
level and subsequent reductions in functional capacity that affect quality
of life. Little research has focused on describing these important side
effects of cancer treatment. The purpose of this descriptive, correlational
study was to determine the relationship between fatigue levels and physical
functioning in women receiving adjuvant therapies for breast cancer. The
Levine Conservation model served as the study’s conceptual framework.
In this model, cancer treatment presents challenges that threaten conservation
of energy (represented by fatigue) and conservation of structural integrity
(represented by physical functioning). The sample included 120 patients
recruited from five academic cancer centers as part of a larger study.
The women were a mean age of 52 years and were receiving adjuvant chemotherapy
(60%) or radiation therapy (40%). Before treatment began and again at
the end of treatment, subjects were assessed for fatigue with the Piper
Fatigue Scale, for self-reported physical functioning with the MOS-SF
36 Physical Functioning Subscale (PhFx), and for objective changes in
functional capacity with the 12-Minute Walk Test. All instruments were
valid, reliable, and widely used in cancer research. Data were analyzed
using Pearson correlations and descriptive statistics. Results indicate
a moderately strong inverse correlation between fatigue levels and self-reported
physical functioning (p = -.45, r < .0001). Although physical functioning
scores were equivalent at pretest, women with the lowest posttest fatigue
levels (lowest quartile) reported a mean PhFx score of 89.6 (possible
0–100) and a mean Walk Test score of 3,385 feet walked in 12 minutes,
while women in the highest quartile of posttest fatigue scores (mean of
6.8 on the PFS) reported a mean PhFx score of 66.5, and a mean Walk Test
score of 2,941 feet. Findings support the need for additional research
as well as for more comprehensive clinical assessment of changes in functional
status accompanying unmanaged fatigue during cancer treatment. The significant
decrease in physical functioning seen in subjects with high fatigue levels
represents a concerning loss of ability to perform daily activities that
may not be readily reversible when cancer treatment ends.
27
CHRONIC SLEEP LOSS IN FAMILY CAREGIVERS: IS DEPRESSION AN OUTCOME? Patricia
A. Carter, PhD, RN, CNS, University of Texas School of Nursing, Austin,
TX.
Problem: Caregivers may experience levels of depression that can impact
their daily functioning, quality of life, and ability to continue in the
caregiver role. Depression is a normal response to a family member’s
diagnosis with cancer; however, other factors amenable to intervention
(chronic sleep loss) may severely exacerbate this response.
Purpose: This pilot project described caregiver sleep and depression patterns
over time and explored the feasibility of data collection methods and
instruments.
Specific Questions: How do family caregivers’ sleep patterns and
depression levels change over time? Are the proposed data collection methods
and instruments feasible?
Framework: Pearlin and colleagues developed a caregiver stress process
framework that illustrates the relationships between physical stressors
(sleep loss) and emotional outcomes (depression). The questions addressed
in this study flow logically from this framework. In order to understand
caregiver depression one must first understand the patterns of sleep loss
and depression over time.
Methods: A descriptive correlational design was used. Ten family caregivers
of persons with advanced stage cancer were recruited from cancer clinics
in central Texas. Weekly sleep quality (Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index
{PSQI}) and depression (Center for Epidemiological Studies Depression
{CESD}) measurements were obtained by telephone. Caregivers wore an actigraph
and recorded daily activities in a log at three separate times (for 72
hours) during the ten-week study. Visual plots of PSQI and CESD scores
were generated for each subject. The actigraph data were analyzed using
Action W software and sleep latency, duration, and efficiency scores were
generated for each subject. Actigraph and PSQI scores were compared.
Findings: Visual plots of caregiver sleep and depression scores reveal
significant changes over time. Actigraph scores are reflective of self-report
(PSQI) of sleep latency, duration, and efficiency.
Implications: This pilot provided a visual mapping of caregivers’
sleep and depression patterns over time. Understanding sleep and depression
patterns is essential to determine the critical time points to administer
and measure interventions. This pilot study provided information regarding
the feasibility of using the Actigraph in this population as well as the
need for weekly measurements of sleep and depression in order to capture
changes over time.
28
MEDICATION SAFETY FOCUS: A MULTIDISCIPLINARY APPROACH TO MEDICATION SAFETY
IN THE ONCOLOGY PATIENT. Mary Ann Long, RN, BSN, Roswell Park Cancer Institute,
Buffalo, NY; Ellen Zupa, RN, MSN, Brian Cotter, RPh, Camille Wicher, RN,
JD, and Meur Wetzler, MD.
This poster presents an overview of the Medication Safety Initiative
conducted at a comprehensive cancer center. This initiative was taken
in response to the concerns raised by the November 1999 Institute of Medicine
report and specifically targeted the systems and procedures involved in
medication administration. Medication safety, while important in all healthcare
agencies, has special significance for both oncology patients and providers.
The scope of this initiative included all of our patient care settings
such as critical care and pediatrics, ambulatory care including chemotherapy
and infusion clinic, the operative center, and all diagnostic and treatment
centers. The interventions that were adopted as a result of the initiative
will be presented and include the following.
- The strategies utilized to conduct an evaluation of our current practice
of medication prescription, preparation, and administration. This included
an analysis of available data, the identification of risk points, and
the subjective concerns identified as related to safety multiple focus
groups. Each participant in these groups was involved in one or more
of the processes included in the medication delivery system.
- The roles of the various members of the multidisciplinary group responsible
for the initiative.
- The findings and recommendations immediately implemented as well as
future plans. The improvements include technology implementation, staff
and patient education, policy and procedure changes, system changes,
and a process for ongoing reporting and analysis of medication variances
that is efficient, comprehensive, and non-punitive.
- Because of the complexity of oncology care, the responsibility for
safe medication delivery is a major component of oncology nursing practice.
This poster provides information that will be applicable to oncology
nurses, their colleagues, and their patients and will contribute to
the goal of an error-free medication delivery system.
29
PREVENTING MEDICATION ERRORS WITH THE POWER OF EVIDENCE-BASED PRACTICE.
Carole W. Sweeney, MSN, RN, AOCN®, Cynthia Briola, BS,
RN, OCN®, Linda Schiech, MSN, RN, AOCN®,
and Janet White, MS, RN, CCRN, Fox Chase Cancer Center, Philadelphia,
PA.
Oncology nurses play a central role in ensuring that patients receive
quality cancer care that includes preventing medication errors. The
recent interest in medical errors stimulated by the Institute of Medicine
report, “To Err is Human: Building a Safer Health System,”
estimates that medical errors kill between 44,000 and 98,000 people
annually in U.S. hospitals. At a comprehensive cancer center, the Nursing
Research Utilization Council (RUC) mission is to provide opportunities
for the conduct and use of research that contribute to the scientific
basis of cancer nursing practice and to improve patient outcomes. One
of the goals of the RUC is to educate nurses in the use of evidence
based research through unit based projects focusing on medication errors.
Using the ONS Position Paper on Prevention and Reporting of Medical
Errors as a framework, the following activities were undertaken by members
of the RUC to facilitate ongoing education for oncology nurses: 1) published
a peer education newsletter analyzing research related to medication
errors, 2) developed and circulated a poster on medication errors that
included a post-test for staff to complete, 3) participated in an institution
wide symposium focusing on the fundamentals of dealing with medical
errors, 4) utilized ONS educational activities and offerings addressing
medication errors, and 5) confirmed that all medication-related policies
and standards of practice are current with research findings. Details
of multi-disciplinary hospital wide activities related to processes
for identifying and reviewing medication errors in a non-punitive setting,
ensuring safety and efficacy of equipment, and systems for analyzing
medication errors are ongoing. The post-test results will be used as
one mechanism for evaluation of the program. Ongoing evaluation, critical
to insuring sustained improvement, is discussed using a standardized
performance improvement model (FOCUS-PDCA). The focus on medication
errors by
the RUC in conjunction with hospital-wide interest has been an important
step aimed at helping oncology nurses to understand their pivotal role
in the reporting, analyzing, and prevention of medication errors, and
safeguarding the outcomes of those entrusted to their care.
30
DEVELOPMENT OF AN AMBULATORY PUMP PROGRAM TO ENHANCE SAFETY FOR PATIENTS
ENROLLED IN CLINICAL TRIALS. Barbara Rattner, MS, RN, Joanne Perri LaFrancesca,
MN, RN, Joan Agretelis, PhD, RNCS-ANP, AOCN®, Massachusetts General
Hospital, Boston, MA; and Gayle Fishman, RN, MBA, Health Care Redesign,
Wellesley, MA.
Background & Rationale: The Massachusetts General Hospital Cancer
Center has expanded patient participation in clinical trials by 50% over
the past three years. Many of these clinical trials require patients to
receive medication via continuous infusion. A variety of ambulatory infusion
pumps were being used for the delivery of both standard and investigational
chemotherapy. Nurses identified a high risk for error because each pump
had different specifications, programming, and operation requirements.
Additionally, home infusion companies are not licensed to monitor drugs
in development. This meant that patients receiving investigational agents
at home were not eligible for home nursing visits, adding to the misgivings
of staff. In response to these concerns, the nursing leadership initiated
the development of a program to address these patient safety issues.
Interventions: A multi-disciplinary committee was convened to examine
our existing resources and ability to manage a self-contained ambulatory
care investigational drug program. One infusion pump was selected which
utilizes bar-code technology and eliminates the potential for human error
in the programming process. A pilot project was undertaken with conventional,
non-vesicant infusional therapy considered a lower risk for patient adverse
events. Patients and families attended a structured education program
developed and presented by a nurse prior to initiating therapy. Twenty-four
hour nursing telephone coverage was provided.
Interpretation: Product reliability testing conducted by our biomedical
engineering department demonstrated safe, reliable delivery rates. Safer
pump technology along with a structured patient/family education process
created an environment of acceptance among our patients and professional
staff. On-call nursing utilization for patient care issues was minimal.
After evaluating the results from the pilot project, the program was expanded
to incorporate patients enrolled in clinical trials.
Discussion: The ambulatory pump program is ready to meet the growing demands
of our clinical trials program. Physicians and nurses have confidence
in this program and technology. Investigators are now mandated to use
this pump for trials involving continuous infusions, eliminating the danger
of multiple infusion pumps.
31
TO ERR IS HUMAN—DESIGNING SAFER SYSTEMS FOR CHEMOTHERAPY ADMINISTRATION.
Rose Taibbi, RN, BSN, OCN®, Diane Gissinger, RN, MSN, OCN®, Gertrude
Kane, RN, MSN, OCN®, Claire Meci, RN, BSN, OCN®, and Anthony Negri,
RPh, North Shore University Hospital, Manhasset, NY.
Chemotherapy errors can be lethal. Investigations of highly publicized
chemotherapy errors show that multiple system failures must occur for
an error to reach the patient. All disciplines involved in ordering, preparing/dispensing,
and administration of chemotherapy must be highly trained and receive
ongoing education. Antineoplastic agents are unique in that there is such
a wide array of doses and schedules used. To address the concerns within
our institution and identify areas for improvement, a multidisciplinary
Chemotherapy Performance Improvement Committee meets monthly. The literature
clearly recommends the use of computerized ordering systems. However,
for institutions without computerized programs, other interventions must
be developed, implemented, and re-evaluated on an ongoing basis. Review
of errors with root cause analysis is crucial to understanding your institution’s
process and potential for improvement. In addition, much can be learned
from “potential errors.” Our focus is on review of orders
that require intervention or revision before the patient is treated. We
identified five levels of severity with the first four reflecting problems
that were corrected prior to treatment. The fifth level reflects any error
that reached the patient. Education focuses on heightening awareness of
the need to report all orders that required interventions. We stressed
non-punitive action, the ability to learn from “potential errors,”
and identification of methods to prevent actual errors. Chemotherapy order
writing guidelines, maximum dosing charts, and guidelines for administration
and monitoring were developed. Most importantly, a multidisciplinary algorithm
of check processes was developed to ensure comprehensive review of each
order by physicians, pharmacists, and nurses. Each discipline understands
their accountability in the process. “Potential errors” are
tracked for trends, and staff is educated accordingly. Staff is recognized
for their assistance with problem identification and reporting. Over the
past year, we administered 50,107 drug preparations, identified 484 “potential
errors,” and had one actual error. Despite the increasing complexity
of treatments, our error rate was .002% using the protocols discussed.
Designing safer systems protects patients and allows oncology nurses to
implement all possible safeguards as we strive for an error rate of zero.
32
IMPROVING SYMPTOM MANAGEMENT IN AN AMBULATORY ONCOLOGY CLINIC. Marybeth
Singer, MS, RN, AOCN®, APRN, BC, and Arati Patel, MD, New England
Medical Center, Boston, MA.
Symptom distress significantly contributes to diminished quality of
living for cancer patients and their families. The JCAHO recently mandated
that certain minimum standards for assessment/treatment/re-assessment
of pain occur throughout the trajectory of illness for patients receiving
care within healthcare systems. Patients with cancer frequently experience
pain, as well as other symptoms, which can lead to distress. Our urban
ambulatory care center implemented a symptom survey for patients to complete
at each clinic visit. Goals of the patient symptom survey were: 1) to
assess and implement strategies to improve symptom outcomes as a quality
improvement initiative, 2) compliance with JCAHO standards for pain management,
and 3) provide a vehicle for increased communication between patients
and clinicians regarding symptom distress. Symptom survey data collection
is continuous. The findings below are reflective of the initial symptom
survey pilot over a period of one month.
Initial data yielded 136 completed symptom surveys, with 80% of those
patients having a hematologic malignancy. The eight most frequent symptoms,
listed in order of severity, were lack of energy, negative quality of
life, difficulty performing activities of daily living, depression, anxiety,
difficulty with concentration, pain, and coping distress. When symptoms
are evaluated based on diagnosis, the rank ordering and severity are similar
regardless of cancer diagnosis. Symptom intensity greater than 7 (0–10
scale) occurred in 35% of patients, 66% of whom had 1–3 concurrent
symptoms with an intensity greater than seven. The most compelling information
was gleaned at the time of follow-up telephone interviews with those patients
with symptom intensity greater than seven. Only 29% of patients had discussed
the symptoms with their MD or NP at the time of their visit. When discussion
occurred with the clinician, 100% of patients felt that steps were taken
to address their symptom distress. When discussion did not occur specific
to symptom survey, 83% of patients felt no steps were taken to address
their symptom distress.
More than 50% of ambulatory oncology patients in our pilot survey reported
symptom distress related to their disease and treatment. Data collection
is on-going as part of a continuous quality improvement initiative to
ensure optimal symptom management for patients.
Comprehensive cancer care means attending to all symptoms associated with
patient distress and allocating resources to meet those needs.
33
EVALUATION OF THE ONS SYMPTOM MANAGEMENT WORKSHOP ON PERIPHERAL NEUROPATHY.
Terri Armstrong, RN, MS, NP, CS, Mark Gilbert, MD, M.D. Anderson Cancer
Center, Houston, TX; Lois Almadrones, RN, MS, C, FNP, MPA, Memorial Sloan-Kettering
Cancer Center, New York, NY; Anita Nirenberg, RN, MSN, Columbia University
School of Nursing, New York, NY; Ruth Gholz, RN, MS, AOCN®, Cincinnati
VAMC, Cincinnati, OH; and Gail Wilkes, RNC, MSN, OCN®, Massachusetts
General Hospital, Boston, MA.
Peripheral neuropathy (PN) is an increasingly common side effect of cancer
and cancer treatment. It is estimated that nearly 20% of all patients
with cancer will experience neuropathy during the course of their illness.
In addition, peripheral neuropathy is a dose-limiting toxicity of three
commonly used chemotherapeutic agents: Paclitaxel, Cisplatin, and Vincristine.
Despite this fact, many oncology nurses are not aware of how to assess
and manage this symptom in their patients.
In an effort to improve knowledge of PN in oncology nurses, the Oncology
Nursing Society, through a grant from Aventis Pharmaceuticals, supported
a workshop for 200 oncology nurses. The workshop consisted of multi-disciplinary
didactic lectures on anatomy, physiology of the nervous system, an overview
of the causes of neuropathy, pain management, physical and occupational
therapy needs, and nursing interventions. In addition, hands-on experience
in exam techniques and case studies were completed. All participants received
a toolkit consisting of workshop content slides, a pocket sized information
card, and instruments including a reflex hammer and tuning fork to assess
patients. Participants agreed to present at least one educational program
on peripheral neuropathy to other nurses or to patients.
To evaluate the effect of the program on participant knowledge levels,
participants completed a pre- and post-test multiple choice questionnaires.
This test was developed by an expert interdisciplinary panel and face
validity was established by administering the pilot test to 10 oncology
nurses. The test underwent minor revisions for clarity. This test was
completed by attendees at the start of the workshop and at the conclusion,
prior to turning in their evaluations. The percentage of correct responses
increased from 76.7% to 99.6% at the completion of the program. A six-month
evaluation to query their individual educational programs, and administer
the workshop test and a self-efficacy questionnaire was also completed
and the results will be reported.
This effort to improve oncology nurse knowledge of this devastating side
effect was shown to improve nurse knowledge by direct testing and can
be utilized as a framework for other symptom management programs.
34
PAIN AND FATIGUE MANAGEMENT: RESULTS OF A NURSING RANDOMIZED CLINICAL
TRIAL. Barbara Given, PhD, RN, FAAN, Michigan State University, East Lansing,
MI; Ruth McCorkle, PhD, RN, FAAN, Yale University, New Haven, CT; Bernadine
Cimprich, PhD, RN, FAAN, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI; and Charles
Given, PhD, Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI.
Patients with breast, colon, lung, and other solid tumors who undergo
a course of chemotherapy are at high risk of experiencing pain and fatigue.
Pain and fatigue can have significant impact on the presence of others
symptoms and upon level of physical functioning. To assist patients to
better control pain and fatigue, a randomized clinical trial (RCT) of
a nurse-directed, 20 week, 10 contact intervention was implemented for
patients undergoing a new course of chemotherapy and their family caregivers.
The purpose of this report is to compare patients undergoing an initial
course of chemotherapy who report pain and fatigue and who are receiving
conventional care alone with those receiving conventional care plus the
nursing intervention with respect to the severity and limitations of pain
and fatigue, and numbers of other symptoms reported at 20 weeks.
A cognitive-behavioral conceptual framework focusing on problem solving
approaches to symptom management, improving physical functioning, and
emotional health were implemented at each contact. Pain and fatigue were
sentinel problems toward which the intervention was directed.
Sample. The sample consisted of 35 patients in each arm of the trial who
reported pain and fatigue at baseline following recruitment and consent.
Seventy-one percent of the sample was female with mean age of 54 (SD =
8). Interviews were conducted at baseline, 10, 20, and 32 weeks. Outcomes
were measured by the brief pain and brief fatigue inventories. All measures
met acceptable psychometric standards.
Results. Groups were assessed for equivalence at baseline and to determine
if there were differences by accrual setting. Analyses of variance were
used to assess group effects, group by time, and group by time by covariates
(age, gender, stage (II or III–IV). Patients who received the intervention
reported significantly less severity and fewer limitations from pain and
fatigue at the 20- and 32-week observations. In addition, patients receiving
the intervention reported fewer “other” symptoms at both observations.
Implications. These data support the need for targeted interventions to
assist patients undergoing chemotherapy to manage pain and fatigue.
35
THE PREVALENCE OF SYMPTOMS CLUSTERS AND COMORBIDITIES IN ONCOLOGY OUTPATIENTS.
Marylin J. Dodd, RN, PhD, FAAN, Christine Miaskowski, RN, PhD, FAAN, Claudia
West, RN, MS, Steven Paul, PhD, and Kathy Lee, RN, PhD, FAAN, University
of California, San Francisco, CA.
The prevalence of a number of symptoms including pain, fatigue, nausea
and vomiting, depression, and sleep disturbance has been investigated
in oncology outpatients. The traditional approach used in these investigations
was to perform detailed assessments of individual symptoms. However, clinical
experience suggests that oncology outpatients present with multiple symptoms
and a variety of comorbid conditions. Therefore, the purposes of this
cross-sectional study, in a sample of oncology outpatients, were: 1) to
determine the prevalence of pain, fatigue, and/or sleep disturbances,
and 2) to determine the prevalence of a number of comorbid conditions.
The UCSF Symptom Management Model served as the conceptual framework for
this study. One hundred oncology outpatients were recruited from three
outpatient settings. Patients were over 18 years of age and were receiving
active treatment for their disease. Patients were asked to complete the
Wisconsin Brief Pain Inventory (BPI), the Lee Fatigue Scale (LFS), the
General Sleep Disturbance Scale (GSDS), and a checklist of common medical
conditions. Patients were categorized into one of eight symptom clusters
using the following cutoffs: a worst pain score of greater than three,
an LFS score of greater than five, and a GSDS score of greater than 60.
Descriptive statistics and frequency distributions were generated. The
average patient was 59.4 years of age, female (76.8%), and had a Karnofsky
score of 77.2. The prevalence of the eight symptom groupings were as follows:
no symptoms, 42.3%; only pain, 10.3%; only fatigue, 6.2%; only sleep disturbance,
8.2%; pain & fatigue, 4.1%, pain & sleep disturbance, 9.3%; fatigue
& sleep disturbance, 6.2%; and pain, fatigue, & sleep disturbance,
13.4%. The most frequently reported comorbid conditions by these patients
were back problems, 65.2%; allergies, 58.5%; headaches, 50.5%; hemorrhoids,
46.3%; arthritis, 33.3%; and hypertension, 30.4%. These findings suggest
that oncology outpatients do experience multiple symptoms simultaneously
and are living with a number of comorbid conditions in addition to their
cancer.
36
INFORMATION AND DECISION PREFERENCES OF MEN WITH PROSTATE CANCER AND THEIR
PARTNERS. B. Joyce Davison, PhD, RN, The Prostate Centre, Vancouver General
Hospital, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada; Lesley F. Degner, PhD,
RN, University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada; S. Larry Goldenberg,
MD, FRCSC, FACS, and Martin E. Gleave, MD, FRCSC, FACS, The Prostate Centre,
Vancouver General Hospital, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada.
Previous research has shown the majority of men newly diagnosed with
prostate cancer do want to be involved in medical decision making, and
they want to be informed. However, the information of preferences of partners
and the extent to which they want to be involved in treatment decision
making has not previously been studied. The purpose of this study was
to identify and compare information and decision preferences of men with
prostate cancer and their partners at the time of diagnosis. A convenience
sample of 80 couples was recruited from the Prostate Centre in Vancouver,
Canada. Participants used a touch screen computer program consisting of
two previously used measures with this population: 1) Control Preferences
Scale, used to elicit patient preferences for control over medical decision
making (based on Unfolding Theory), and 2) Information Survey Questionnaire
(based on Thurstone methodology). Results showed the vast majority of
men wanted to participate in decision making with their physician (92.5%),
and partners (100%). The majority (55%) of partners wanted to play a collaborative
role in treatment decision making. Couples identified prognosis, stage
of disease, treatment options, and side effects as their top four information
preferences. Men ranked information on sexuality more important than partners
(P = .004), and partners ranked information on home self care higher than
men (P = .01). Men who had sons, a positive family history, and lower
levels of education ranked heredity risk significantly higher (P = .001).
Profiles of information categories did not differ according to role preferences
of either men or partners. The computer program has been shown to be a
reliable and acceptable method of assessing the information and decision
preferences of these couples. Group profiles demonstrated low to moderate
agreement, but individual profiles were shown to be highly reliable. Findings
support the need for using an individualized approach to the provision
of information to these individuals at the time of diagnosis. Print outs
from this computer program can be used to guide information counseling
sessions in a variety of outpatient oncology settings.
37
CULTURAL INFLUENCES ON BREAST CANCER EXPERIENCE: KOREAN WOMEN IN SOUTH
KOREA. Eun-Ok Lee, RN, DNS, Seoul National University College of Nursing,
Seoul, South Korea; Eun-Ok Im, PhD, MPH, RN, CNS, University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee,
Milwaukee, WI; and Young Sook Park, PhD, Seoul National University, Seoul,
Korea.
Women’s breast cancer experiences are influenced by a number of
contextual factors, one of which is culture. Despite the importance of
consideration on cultural background in understanding women’s breast
cancer experiences, very little is known about it. The purpose of the
study is to explore cultural meanings of breast cancer among Korean women
in South Korea and determine cultural impacts on breast cancer experiences.
Transition theory and feminist approach are used as theoretical frameworks.
This is a descriptive longitudinal study utilizing methodological triangulation,
and only qualitative findings are presented here. Fifty Korean patients
who were newly diagnosed with a plan of surgery and subsequent chemotherapy
and not having severe fatigue at the time of recruitment were recruited
for the quantitative phase using a convenience sampling method; then 15
among them were recruited for the qualitative phase. Qualitative data
were collected using two-hour, in-depth interviews, and analyzed using
thematic analysis including line-by-line coding, categorization, inductive
and deductive cognitive process, writing memos, and group discussions.
The findings indicated unique impacts of Korean culture on women’s
breast cancer experiences. The themes included: (a) “I did wrong”;
(b) “I cannot ask male physicians”; (c) “I don’t
want to show the operation site to my husband”; and (d) “I
do household tasks by myself.” The themes certainly reflected patriarchal
cultural influences and modesty issues related to Confucianism. Based
on the findings, some implications including consciousness-raising on
patriarchal cultural impacts and its unfairness, empowerment by providing
information, and encouragement of women’s participation in decision
making process were proposed.
38
“TC CHECK”—TEEN CANCER AWARENESS PROGRAM. Elaine Kocsis,
RN, OCN®, CCRP, South Pointe Hospital/Cleveland Clinic Health System,
Warrensville Heights, OH; Bev Waters Shankman, BA, MA, Cleveland Clinic
Health System, Mayfield Heights, OH; and Barbara Demagall, RN, South Pointe
Hospital/Cleveland Clinic Health System, Warrensville Heights, OH.
The incidence of testicular cancer in the United States has almost doubled
since the 1930s and continues to climb. The age group at highest risk
is the 15–35 year old men. Testicular cancer is curable by 90%–99%
if reported and treated early. Unfortunately, testicular cancer has become
the taboo cancer of the 2000s, much as breast cancer was in the 1960s–1970s.
As with breast cancer, most testicular cancers are discovered by the individual
themselves.
Public awareness and education in this country are sorely lacking. It
was discovered that most high schools do not include TSE or BSE as part
of the curriculum. However, once the need for this education is brought
to the attention of the administrators and educators there is enthusiasm
and willingness to permit healthcare professionals into the classroom
to instruct the students. Most health education classes in the public
schools are co-educational.
This required a needs re-assessment and it was believed that testicular
and breast cancer issues could be presented in a manner that was educational
and non-threatening to a mixed gender class.
The purpose of this abstract is to describe the components, implementation,
and results of this program which targets 10th grade students in health
education classes.
The objectives of the TC check program are that the student will: 1) recognize
signs, symptoms, and identify risk factors associated with breast and
testicular cancer, 2) demonstrate the correct methods of TSE and BSE,
and 3) will maintain a healthy lifestyle through monthly self-exam. These
goals are reached by use of lecture, video, anatomical models, handouts,
and reinforced by the “TC Jeopardy Game.”
In 2000 the TC Check program was presented to 214 people at three health
fairs and six health education classes by a team of healthcare workers.
Participant ages ranged from 8–63 years of age. One hundred thirty
six 15–16 year olds attended at school presentations. Ninety five
percent rated the program as helpful; 5% had no opinion. Eighty six percent
stated they acquired new information. First time instruction for TSE was
67%; BSE was 74%. Due to the efforts of such celebrities as Lance Armstrong,
Tom Green, and Scott Hamilton, general awareness in the targeted age group
has increased. Healthcare professionals can benefit from this changing
awareness by devising or utilizing programs directed at young adults in
the classroom. The TC Check program can easily be adapted to a variety
of age groups and settings including colleges, health fairs, young people
groups such as scouts, and work places with equal success.
39
A TOBACCO CESSATION COUNSELING PROGRAM FOR HOSPITALIZED PATIENTS. Janice
Kjellberg, RN, Karen Swenson, RN, MS, AOCN®, Park Nicollet Institute,
Minneapolis, MN; and Donald Pine, MD, Park Nicollet Clinic, Minnetonka,
MN.
A hospital stay is an opportune time for tobacco cessation intervention
because tobacco bans force abstinence, patients are removed from their
usual triggers for tobacco use, patients are more focused on health concerns,
and there is access to knowledgeable care providers. The tobacco cessation
counseling program at this Midwest urban community hospital was developed
out of a NIH-funded study that compared interventions to help hospitalized
patients quit smoking. The study found that patients receiving counseling
and follow-up had a 10% higher quit rate than those receiving less intensive
interventions. The main goal of the current program is to help hospitalized
patients quit tobacco, and to abstain from tobacco use after discharge.
Eligibility criteria includes use of tobacco within the past three months;
age greater than 17 years; not admitted for mental health, substance abuse,
or eating disorder; and not too ill or impaired to participate. Intervention
is given by a trained tobacco counselor who establishes eligibility, determines
patient readiness to quit, and provides bedside counseling and appropriate
tobacco cessation literature. The intervention is documented in patient
charts and pharmacotherapy is recommended to the physician when appropriate.
Tobacco users who are ready to quit are also offered three to six follow-up
phone calls to promote abstinence after discharge. Program evaluation
is done with a mailed survey or by phone if the participant does not respond.
The survey assesses six-month quit rates, patient satisfaction with the
program, level of program participation, and use of pharmacotherapy or
other cessation aids. Over 20 months, 1,263 patients received in-hospital
counseling, and 698 patients agreed to a six-month follow-up. Of the 244
for whom follow-up data is available, the quit rate is 105/244 (43%).
From this group, 73 (30%) have not used tobacco since hospitalization
and an additional 32 (13%) have been abstinent for the past seven days.
Of the respondents, 78% found in-hospital counseling helpful, and 71%
found phone follow-up helpful.
Thirty percent of participants used the nicotine patch and 24% used Zyban.
The results support the efficacy of this tobacco cessation counseling
program in the hospital setting.
40
EFFICACY OF A REPRESENTATIONAL INTERVENTION FOR CANCER PAIN. Sandra Ward,
PhD, RN, FAAN, professor, Ron C. Serlin, PhD, Heidi Donovan, MS, RN, Sigga
Gunnarsdottir, MS, RN, and Susan Hughes, MS, RN, University of Wisconsin,
Madison, WI.
Purpose: The purpose of this study was to test an educational intervention
to improve pain management. The hypotheses were: (1) The intervention
will decrease beliefs that are barriers to pain management, decrease pain
severity, and improve QOL, and (2) Changes in beliefs (barriers) will
mediate the effect of the intervention on pain severity and QOL.
Theoretical Framework: Leventhal’s Common Sense Model, a theory
explicating the role of cognitive representations in coping with health
problems, guided development of the representational approach to patient
education which, in turn, guided development of a specific educational
intervention—a Representational Intervention to Decrease Cancer
Pain (RIDcancerPain).
Design: Randomized two-group design (RIDcancerPain versus Standard Education[SE]).
Valid, reliable measures of barriers, pain severity, and QOL were used
at baseline (T1), one month later (T2), and two months later (T3).
Sample: Patients with advanced cancer, 18 years or older, who had pain
in the past week were eligible to participate. Two hundred twenty two
subjects were recruited; 150 completed the study.
Findings: Hypotheses were partially supported. There was no main effect
for group on T1 to T2 changes in outcome variables. However, there was
a group effect on change in barriers from T1 to T3; those in the RIDcancerPain
condition showed a greater decrease compared to those in SE [t(124) =
2.04, p = .02]. In addition, there was a group effect on T1 to T3 change
in pain severity, with those in the RIDcancerPain condition improving
compared to those in SE [t(136) = 2.35, p = .02]. The change in barriers
from T1 to T3 mediated the effect of the intervention on the change in
pain severity from T1 to T3. There was no main effect of group on T1 to
T3 change in overall QOL.
Conclusions: The representational approach to patient education shows
promise in that RIDcancerPain had a positive effect on some but not all
outcomes.
Implications: Further testing of a strengthened version of RIDcancerPain
should be done, and the representational approach to education needs to
be tested in other health problems. Clinicians could consider systematic
interventions to overcome patient-related barriers to pain management.
41
MAKING THE CHOICE: HOW WOMEN AT RISK FOR BREAST CANCER FEEL ABOUT PROPHYLACTIC
MASTECTOMY TO REDUCE BREAST CANCER RISK IF THEY WERE TO HAVE A POSITIVE
BRCA GENETIC TEST. Karen Greco, RN, MN, ANP, oncology nurse practitioner,
doctoral student, Nancy Press, PhD, Oregon Health & Science University,
Portland, OR; and Wylie Burke, MD, PhD, University of Seattle, Seattle,
WA.
Purpose/Objectives: This study is a secondary analysis of some qualitative
data from the study, “Family Disclosure of Cancer Risk: An Ethnographic
Study.” The study purpose is to better understand how women at risk
for breast cancer feel about prophylactic mastectomy as an option to reduce
breast cancer risk if they were to have a positive BRCA genetic test.
Sample: Data are from interviews with 246 women aged 40 to 60, of varying
ethnicity, family history of breast cancer (negative, positive, borderline),
and educational level.
Theoretical/Scientific Framework: This secondary analysis used grounded
theory. The original study is a quantitative and descriptive ethnographic
study.
Design: Data were collected in the original study using semi-structured
interviews to assess women’s attitudes toward and hypothetical interest
in genetic susceptibility testing for breast cancer.
Methods: Data from four questions in the original interviews were analyzed
using a grounded theory approach.
Data Analysis: Open coding was done to identify concepts. Data were analyzed
independently by three researchers; myself, the PI, and the co-investigator.
Themes were identified and diagramed. Discussion of data analysis among
the three researchers occurred throughout the process.
Findings: Women’s responses represented a continuum from “it
is a mutilation” to “yes, it wouldn’t bother me at all.”
The primary theme identified was “making the choice.” Women
made a clear distinction between agreeing to have a predisposition genetic
test for BRCA and agreeing to have prophylactic mastectomies should the
test result be positive. Many women said they would obtain second opinions
and would mistrust their provider for suggesting such radical surgery.
Four subthemes were identified: search for alternatives, inadequate provider,
let the cancer come, and keeping my parts.
Conclusions: Most women responded that they would likely agree to have
a predisposition genetic test for BRCA if it were recommended by their
physician. However, they would not automatically agree to prophylactic
mastectomies even if that were the best treatment available to reduce
breast cancer risk.
Implications for Research/Practice: Oncology nurses need to understand
that although prophylactic mastectomies may be effective in reducing breast
cancer risk, women may have strong responses to the suggestion.
42
PRECHEMOTHERAPY SELF-CARE MANAGEMENT INSTRUCTION IN OLDER MALE VETERANS
WITH A CANCER DIAGNOSIS: AN EXPERIMENTAL STUDY. Virginia Sicola, PhD,
APN, AOCN®, RN, oncology coordinator, Amarillo VA Health Care System,
Amarillo, TX; and Gary Kelley, PhD, West Texas A&M University, Canyon,
TX.
Instruction in self-care management before chemotherapy is provided to
older adult males without knowing if it is beneficial. Therefore, the
purpose of this prospective, randomized, control study was to examine
the benefit of prechemotherapy self-care management instruction on post-treatment
mental status, physical performance, and frequency of side effects in
older male veterans diagnosed with cancer. The theoretical framework used
Orem’s self-care as the process adults use to regulate their own
functioning. A cancer patient experiences limitations and side effects
of treatment, thus experiences a self-care deficit. The nurses’
role is to reduce the deficit. The sample included 67 veterans with cancer
receiving at least two cycles of chemotherapy. No subjects younger than
55 years of age, with a previous cancer history, alcoholism, drug dependency,
or mental deficiency were included. Each veteran was given the valid and
reliable Mini Mental State Examination (MMSE) and Karnofsky Performance
Status Scale (KPS) score by the research assistant (RA). Then, the veteran
was randomly assigned to the control or experimental group by the researcher
who gave both groups a 15-minute introduction to chemotherapy and its
side effects. The experimental group received further instructions in
self-care management. Prior to the second treatment, the RA retested the
patients. Each subject reported the number of medically-treated side effects.
With 35 control and 32 experimental subjects, the data were analyzed using
t tests and means. Results showed that following treatment, the KPS approached
significance (p value = 0.110) with the experimental group’s mean
score dropping 2.8 points compared to the control group’s score
dropping 5.8. Side effects significantly lower for the experimental group
included constipation (p value = 0.009) and dizziness (p value = 0.05).
At the 0.15 level of significance, the experimental group experienced
less nausea, vomiting, and sleep difficulties. The findings indicate that
self-care management provided prior to chemotherapy improves physical
performance and reduced some side effects in older veterans. Further research
calls to extend this study by evaluating older patients beyond the second
cycle. In practice, instruction in self-care before chemotherapy is of
benefit for older men.
43
CANCER-RELATED FATIGUE: “IT’S SO MUCH MORE THAN JUST BEING
TIRED.” Horng-Shiuann Wu, RN, PhD(c), School of Nursing, and Maryellen
McSweeney, PhD, Saint Louis University, Saint Louis, MO.
Fatigue is highly prevalent among persons with cancer and has great impact
on their lives, but the subjective experience of cancer-related fatigue
(CRF) is not well understood. Because CRF is a subjective, multidimensional
experience, developing a knowledge base about and effective interventions
for CRF require understanding the phenomenon from the individual’s
perspective.
Purpose/Objectives: This study explored the meaning of CRF from the person’s
perspective to learn about the actual experience of fatigue.
Scientific Framework: A phenomenological perspective served as the philosophical
framework of this study. Human behaviors were understood from the individual’s
own context; CRF was interpreted through the meanings individual brought
to it.
Design: Qualitative methods were used to understand the individual’s
experience of CRF.
Sample: The sample consisted of 10 female patients with breast cancer
currently receiving chemotherapy from a freestanding clinic in St. Louis,
Missouri. Two African American and eight Caucasion women, aged 30 to 73
years, with various cancer stages, participated. Criterion sampling was
used.
Methods: After giving informed consent, the subjects participated in audio-taped,
semi-structured, 30–60 minute individual interviews (n = 10) and
a two-week daily fatigue diary activity (n = 6 returned).
Data Analysis: Content analysis, using open and axial coding and coding
frames, guided the coding and analysis in this study.
Findings: The analysis resulted in the following thematic categories:
unique fatigue, physical sensations, emotional sensations, changes in
daily life, causes of fatigue, fatigue management, fatigue trajectory,
and reflection/meanings.
Conclusions: CRF as a multidimensional phenomenon that affects all aspects
of an individual’s life is evidenced. Participants described that
they were experiencing an unexpected degree and kind of fatigue that is
much more than just being tired. Lack of awareness and knowledge to confront
CRF were identified across interviews. Individualized strategies were
learned from the person’s own experiences.
Implications: The findings will help cancer patients and clinicians better
understand CRF from a holistic approach. They may prompt the development
of interventions to help chemotherapy patients anticipate and respond
to CRF. A CRF instrument is in development based on the findings of this
study.
44
NURSE INTERNSHIP FOR A BLOOD AND MARROW TRANSPLANT UNIT: AN APPROACH TO
RECRUITMENT AND RETENTION. Katherine B. Mishaw, RN, MS, AOCN®, University
of Texas M.D. Anderson Cancer Center, Houston, TX.
Today’s nursing shortage is evidenced by fewer nurses entering
the workforce, acute nursing shortages in certain geographic areas, and
a shortage of nurses prepared to meet specialty patient needs in a changing
healthcare environment. This is clearly evident in the blood and marrow
transplant unit at MDACC, which processes approximately 600 transplants
per year. It is a challenge to recruit nurses with cancer experience,
much less, with a background in this specialty.
Although nurses like the challenging environment, including the latest
treatment and technology, many verbalize that the unit is too daunting
in terms of the learning curve. Applicants are concerned whether the institution
is committed to training for the nurses. In response to this concern,
this BMT unit refined its current curriculum to include a three-month
“internship program.” The program includes the hospital orientation,
the BMT unit orientation, and additional clinical experiences to provide
the “big picture” of the transplant process.
These experiences include the ambulatory BMT clinics (observe both the
pretransplant workup and the immediate post hospitalization needs for
both the allogeneic and autologous transplant patients), pheresis unit
(observing photopheresis, stem cell, single donor platelet, and donor
lymphocyte collections), and observation in the chronic GVHD clinic. Tools
developed for the internship program include an orientation pathway, BMT
course curriculum (includes ONS SIG recommendations and additional hematology/oncology),
an orientee study guide, and patient case studies/vignettes. These vignettes
are reviewed in weekly post-clinical seminars to enhance critical thinking,
assessment, data collection, priority setting, and decision-making skills
in these novice nurses. This program empowers the nurse with the knowledge
to provide competent care for this patient population and may serve as
a model for orientation of the advanced practice nurses for BMT as well
as future “residency” programs for nurses in BMT arena. This
presentation will detail this program, the tools utilized, cost analysis,
and the outcomes.
45
STAFF-DRIVEN ASSESSMENT OF RETENTION ISSUES FOR ONCOLOGY NURSES. Elaine
M. Sein, RN, BSN, OCN®, Maureen Mullin, RN, BSN, OCN®, and Anne
Jadwin, RN, MSN, AOCN®, Fox Chase Cancer Center, Philadelphia, PA.
The national nursing shortage has hospitals competing for nurses from
a continually diminishing pool. Competent oncology nurses are an extremely
valuable commodity in this competitive market. The increased number of
open nursing positions presented an opportunity for the Retention and
Recruitment Committee at Fox Chase Cancer Center, an NCI-designated comprehensive
cancer center, to address not only recruitment issues but also to implement
a plan to retain quality oncology nurses. Within a shared governance model,
this committee affords the staff nurse leadership opportunities that will
directly affect nursing satisfaction. In order to address the issues,
an assessment of retention factors at this Magnet hospital would provide
crucial data.
In the fall of 2000, surveys were sent to all nursing staff. The survey
instrument included seventeen Likert scale questions, a demographics section,
a chart to rank order the three best and three least favorite things about
working at this facility, and a section for open commentary and suggestions.
The 80% response rate from full- and part-time staff was felt to be a
representative sample. Analysis of the survey was done ensuring respondent
anonymity. The top three retention factors were commitment to oncology
nursing, competence of nursing staff, and quality of nursing care. The
three least favorable factors were non-competitive salary scale, communication
issues, and poor physical work environment. A demographic breakdown according
to age, years in nursing, educational background, and years of service
provided pertinent data as to what was valued by individual groups.
The results of the survey were presented to nursing administration and
hospital administration. A summary letter was distributed to the nursing
staff as a spin-off for dialogue at open nursing forums held between nursing
staff and members of nursing administration. Oncology nurses have been
empowered to impact nursing retention and recruitment as evidenced by
salary adjustments, expanded benefits, increased tuition reimbursement,
flexible scheduling options, enhanced unit and interdepartmental communication,
and a plan for physical renovations. The retention and recruitment subcommittee
has been expanded to include members from nursing administration, human
resources and marketing for a more comprehensive approach in addressing
retention issues.
46
COLLABORATIVE NURSING EDUCATION: PAVING THE WAY FOR EXCELLENCE IN ONCOLOGY
NURSING PRACTICE. Marilyn Tuls Halstead, RN, PhD, AOCN®, and Sharon
Eifried, RN, PhD, Towson University, Towson, MD.
Qualified, caring nurses are a critical component of oncology nursing
practice. However, because of the current nursing shortage it is imperative
to develop innovative methods to educate generic nursing students, RN
to BSN students, and master’s level practitioners about the practice
of oncology nursing. To achieve this goal, Greater Baltimore Medical Center
(GBMC) and the Towson University (TU) Department of Nursing created a
unique partnership that establishes GBMC as a clinical education center
of TU, bringing nursing education and practice together. TU is helping
GBMC to upgrade the credentials of oncology nurses. Incentives to complete
BS and MS degrees include scholarships, location of classes in the hospital
complex, and scheduling accommodations. Expected outcomes for GBMC and
the community at large are that the need for qualified oncology nurses
and quality oncology nursing care will be met. Under the terms of the
agreement, GBMC will provide additional experiences for students, as well
as collaborative relationships in clinical, research, and teaching opportunities.
The role and responsibility of a master’s prepared oncology “teacher-practitioner”
will be developed through master’s level education. Members of the
GBMC oncology staff will work with students in teaching and supervisory
roles in order to optimize the experiences of nursing students during
their oncology clinical experiences. Expected outcomes for TU are that
students will gain quality educational experiences, scholarship assistance,
and enhanced faculty expertise.
Through these efforts, oncology nursing leadership will become more visible.
GBMC is one of the few community hospitals that are nationally recognized
for quality cancer care. Because of the multifaceted oncology care available
at GBMC, the student clinical experience is rich and holistic. Of particular
note is GBMC’s focus on psychosocial care throughout the cancer
experience. GBMC facilitates the development of expert oncology nurses,
as they become leaders in the field. This partnership also provides an
opportunity for staff, faculty, and students to investigate joint research
activity related to oncology nursing practice.
47
CLINICAL SKILLS, CRITICAL THINKING, AND COMMUNICATION: USING A LEARNING
CONTRACT TO DEVELOP THE NEW ONCOLOGY NURSE. Ellen Cowan, RN, BSN, OCN®,
and Linda Hood, RN, MSN, AOCN®, Duke University Health System, Durham,
NC.
A nurse internship is one strategy to retain and develop new nurses. New
nurses may be attracted to an internship because of the additional structure,
support, time, and opportunities offered during the first years of practice.
Knowing that nursing students receive little specialty education in oncology,
institutions develop internships to be competitive during a nursing shortage.
However, the intern looking for clinical experience may become dissatisfied
when personal goals do not match institutional expectations. For an institution,
additional resources and financial bonuses may attract staff, but there
is no legal guarantee that the intern will remain employed long enough
for the institution to recoup their investment.
These issues were identified as major factors in the success of an oncology
internship program. To address these concerns at Duke University Medical
Center (DUMC), a learning contract was developed to clarify goals and
expectations for the intern and the institution. The goals for the first
six months of practice focused on demonstrating basic nursing competency
as an RN within the DUMC system for the oncology unit population. During
the second six months of practice, goals focused on developing the specialized
knowledge required to manage the oncology patient and to provide educational
rotations to sites across the oncology continuum of care. Goals for the
second clinical year of the internship involved professional development
and oncology nursing certification.
Del Bueno’s model of performance-based development was used in writing
measurable objectives for three areas, clinical skills, critical thinking
skills, and interpersonal skills to direct the learning activities needed
to demonstrate professional practice as an oncology nurse. The contract
included intern responsibilities, mentor resources, and target dates for
completing objectives. By tailoring the experience to the needs of the
adult learner, increased commitment demonstrated by retention and attainment
of professional perspectives will be evidenced and are being evaluated
as outcomes of the program. The intern also is evaluated based on the
objectives identified for each of the time frames within the two-year
period. This presentation will describe the evaluation and implications
of using a learning contract to enhance commitment to an oncology nurse
internship.
48
NOVEL IDEAS FOR BREAST CANCER DIAGNOSIS AND TREATMENT: THE CONCEPT OF
cDNA MICROANALYSIS. Arlene Berman, RN, National Cancer Institute, National
Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD; Georgia Cusack, MS, RN, Kim Maynard,
BSN, RN, Clinical Center, National Institutes of Health; and JoAnne Zujewski,
MD, National Cancer Institute, National Institutes of Health.
In 2001, approximately 192,000 women will be diagnosed with breast cancer
and 40,600 women will die from the disease. Until now, we have relied
upon histologic classification and the testing of a few prognostic markers
by pathologists as our way of classifying tumors. The majority of oncology
nurses are familiar with the prognostic indicators of tumor size, lymph
node status, estrogen and progesterone receptors, and, more recently,
HER2 status. What is not clearly understood is why two breast cancer patients,
with identical prognostic indicators, can get the same chemotherapy or
hormonal treatments, and yet have different outcomes. Complementary DNA
micro array is a powerful new technology that allows the simultaneous
measurement of the expression of a large number of genes and has the potential
for tumor characterization, and may make it possible to predict patient
response to therapy. The application of a large number of genes in a condensed
array on glass slides comprises a DNA micro array. Genetic material from
normal and tumor tissues is extracted, transcribed into cDNA, and labeled
with fluorescent dye. The fluorescent color that results from the cDNA
binding to the slide can tell us whether a set of genes are over expressed
or under expressed compared to a reference standard. This information
may help us identify gene patterns that predict for tumor response or
drug resistance. Researchers at the National Cancer Institute are using
this technology in a phase II neoadjuvant trial of women with stage II
and III breast cancer. With this population, we are able to obtain tumor
tissue before and during chemotherapy and apply this technology to look
for patterns of gene expression. This technology may reveal to us hidden
relationships that go beyond the pathological appearance of a tumor. Oncology
nurses need to have a working knowledge of available technology for breast
cancer in order to assist patients in understanding potential treatment
options. Our hope is that in the future we will be able to apply this
technology to tailor therapy to an individual’s tumor abnormality
and therefore improve patient outcomes.
49
FISH TESTING ENSURES ACCURATE IDENTIFICATION OF HER2-POSITIVE PATIENTS.
Nathalie Chorn, RN, OCN®, University of California, Los Angeles, CA.
Objectives: Herceptin (trastuzumab) is a humanized monoclonal antibody
that has antitumor activity in HER2-positive breast cancer. Over expression
of HER2 is frequently assessed using a standardized, semiquantitative
immunohistochemistry (IHC) assay. An IHC score of 2+ or 3+ (on a scale
of 0–3+) was used as the entry requirement for Herceptin clinical
studies. Additional analyses have shown that HER2 gene amplification,
identified by fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH), occurs in 89%
of 3+ tumors and in 24% of 2+ tumors, and that measurement of patient
HER2 status by FISH may be a more accurate method of identifying patients
for Herceptin treatment. Our primary objectives were to evaluate testing
results of IHC assays and to reiterate the importance of accurate patient
identification through the use of FISH testing for IHC-negative (0, 1+,
and 2+) patients.
Methods: Our experience has shown the need to retest patients who initially
test IHC 1+ and 2+ for HER2 over expression (1+ is considered mildly negative,
and 2+ is considered mildly positive). Some of these patients continue
to show clinical signs of aggressive disease and may benefit from further
testing with FISH for HER2 gene amplification.
Results: Four hundred fifty one subjects who enrolled in the combination
therapy pivotal trial were retrospectively tested using FISH. All were
positive by IHC (i.e., 2+ and 3+). In the FISH-negative group, 38% (n
= 56) were in the chemotherapy-alone arm and 38% (n = 50) were in the
chemotherapy + trastuzumab arm. There appeared to be no benefit in adding
trastuzumab to the FISH-negative group. In the FISH-positive group, only
31% (n = 169) of the subjects enrolled in the chemotherapy-alone arm responded
compared with 54% (n = 176) of subjects who responded to the chemotherapy
+ Herceptin arm, therefore confirming the benefit of adding Herceptin
to first-line metastatic breast cancer treatment.
Conclusion: Proper identification of patients who may benefit from the
use of Herceptin is important in providing quality patient care. Although
IHC testing is commonly used to determine the level of HER2 protein over
expression, FISH testing for HER2 gene amplification appears to be the
most accurate measure for selecting patients who will benefit from Herceptin
therapy.
50
MYLOTARG™—THE NEW ANTIBODY TARGETED CHEMOTHERAPY. Betty Prokop,
RN, BSN, and Tracy Gosselin, RN, MSN, AOCN®, Duke Medical
Center, Durham, NC.
Due to the incidence of relapsed AML, researchers continue to look for
innovative treatments that provide patients with a durable remission.
One of the newest advances in the treatment of AML is an antibody-targeted
chemotherapy known as, Mylotarg.
Mylotarg combines specific targeting of an antibody with the antitumor
activity of a highly potent chemotherapeutic agent that affects the CD
33 antigen. Mylotarg is indicated for patients with CD 33+ AML in first
relapse who are 60+ years of age and who are not candidates for other
cytoxic therapies.
With advances in treatment, oncology nurses face the challenge of caring
for this predominantly elderly population that often has other co-morbid
diseases. The vast array of side effects/complications includes severe
thrombocytopenia, neutropenia, anemia, bleeding, and infections including
sepsis and pneumonia. Adverse events include fever, chills, nausea, emesis,
asthenia, diarrhea, abdominal pain, headache, stomatitis, dyspnea, epistaxis,
hypokalemia, anorexia, constipation, local reaction, and non-specific
rash.
Due to the possibility of this population having a complicated medical
history, oncology nurses attempt to minimize the treatment related side
effects and enhance patient satisfaction through patient education and
early recognition of symptoms. Patient/family teaching should include
specific side effects, signs & symptoms of toxicity, standard precautions,
and self-care needs.
The education of oncology nurses is imperative with the administration
of Mylotarg. In order for nurses to implement excellent care, early identification
and management of these complications is vital to the positive outcome
and survival of this population. There are various avenues available for
nurses to receive the required education needed for patient care. Handouts,
audio-visual tapes, and pharmaceutical-supported in-services are a few
methods being utilized. Unit-based testing can also be performed.
This poster abstract will provide educational tools for nurses that will
enable them to provide better care for patients with relapsed AML.
|