Meta-Analysis of the Effect of Psychoeducational Interventions on Pain in Adults With Cancer

Elizabeth C. Devine

ONF 2003, 30(1), 75-89. DOI: 10.1188/03.ONF.75-89

Purpose/Objectives: To determine the effect of psychoeducational interventions on pain in adults with cancer.

Data Sources: 25 intervention studies published from 1978-2001.

Data Synthesis: When analyzed across all studies, a statistically significant, beneficial effect on pain was found. However, threats to validity were present in some studies. The most serious of these involved a lack of random assignment to treatment condition and a floor effect on pain. When limited to the studies with the best methodologic quality, the effect on pain continued to be statistically significant. Effect on pain by type of treatment was examined and found to be somewhat variable and limited by the small number of studies testing each type of treatment.

Conclusions: Methodologic quality was variable. Reasonably strong evidence exists for relaxation-based cognitive-behavioral interventions, education about analgesic usage, and supportive counseling. Minimal data were available about the relative effectiveness of different types of psychoeducational interventions because few studies included within-study contrasts of different experimental interventions and usual care was not well documented.

Implications for Nursing: Psychoeducational interventions are not a substitute for analgesics, but they may serve as adjuvant therapy. Assessment and clinical judgment are critical. The intervention must be acceptable to patients and not too burdensome for patients in pain to use.

Jump to a section

    References

    Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. (2002). Management of cancer symptoms: Pain, depression and fatigue [AHRQ Publication No. 02-E031]. Rockville, MD: Author.

    Ali, F.F. (1990). The effect of individual hypnosis on stress, anxiety, and intractable pain experienced by Lebanese cancer patients. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, United States International University, San Diego, CA.

    Arathuzik, D. (1991). Pain experience for metastatic breast cancer patients. Unraveling the mystery. Cancer Nursing, 14, 41-48.

    Arathuzik, D. (1994). Effects of cognitive-behavioral strategies on pain in cancer patients. Cancer Nursing, 17, 207-214.

    Banning, A., Sjogren, P., & Henriksen, H. (1991). Pain causes in 200 patients referred to a multidisciplinary cancer pain clinic. Pain, 45, 45-48.

    Beck, S.C.L. (1988). The effect of the therapeutic use of music on cancer related pain. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Utah, Salt Lake City.

    Beck, S.L. (1991). The therapeutic use of music for cancer-related pain. Oncology Nursing Forum, 18, 1327-1337.

    Benor, D.E., Delbar, V., & Krulik, T. (1998). Measuring impact of nursing intervention on cancer patients' ability to control symptoms. Cancer Nursing, 21, 320-334.

    Bonica, J.J. (1990). Cancer pain. In J.J. Bonica (Ed.), The management of pain (pp. 400-460). Philadelphia: Lea and Febiger.

    Carroll, D., & Seers, K. (1998). Relaxation for the relief of chronic pain: A systematic review. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 27, 476-487.

    Cleeland, C.S., Gonin, R., Hatfield, A.K., Edmonson, J.H., Blum, R.H., Stewart, J.A., et al. (1994). Pain and its treatment in outpatients with metastatic cancer. New England Journal of Medicine, 330, 592-596.

    Clotfelter, C.E. (1999). The effect of an educational intervention on decreasing pain intensity in elderly people with cancer. Oncology Nursing Forum, 26, 27-33.

    Cohen, J. (1969). Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences. New York: Academic Press.

    Cook, T.D., & Campbell, D.T. (1979). Quasi-experimentation design and analysis issues for field settings. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.

    Coyle, N., Adelhardt, J., Foley, K.M., & Portenoy, R.K. (1990). Character of terminal illness in the advanced cancer patient: Pain and other symptoms during the last four weeks of life. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management, 5, 83-93.

    Cuenot, L.R. (1994). Effects of brief adjunctive music therapy on chronic cancer pain intensity. Unpublished master's thesis, University of Florida, Gainesville.

    Dalton, J.A. (1984). An analysis of the effect of an adult-oriented teaching-learning transaction on pain relief for cancer patients treated in the outpatient clinic of a large North Carolina medical center. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, North Carolina State University, Raleigh.

    Dalton, J.A. (1987). Education for pain management: A pilot study. Patient Education and Counseling, 9, 155-165.

    Darraugh, K.M. (1978). Reduction of pain levels in cancer patients through a relaxation technique. Unpublished master's thesis, Adelphi University, Garden City, NY.

    Devine, E.C. (1992). Effects of psychoeducational care for adult surgical patients: A meta-analysis of 191 studies. Patient Education and Counseling, 19, 129-142.

    Devine, E.C., & Reifschneider, E. (1995). A meta-analysis of the effects of psychoeducational care in adults with hypertension. Nursing Research, 44, 237-245.

    Devine, E.C., & Westlake, S.K. (1995). The effects of psychoeducational care provided to adults with cancer: Meta-analysis of 116 studies. Oncology Nursing Forum, 22, 1369-1381.

    de Wit, R., van Dam, F., Zandbelt, L., van Buuren, A., van der Heijden, K., Leenhouts, G., et al. (1997). A pain education program for chronic cancer pain patients: Follow-up results from a randomized controlled trial. Pain, 73, 55-69.

    Farzanegan, Z.M. (1989). Effects of individualized patient therapy programs on pain, psychological distress, and quality of life of cancer patients. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Southern California, Los Angeles.

    Fulmer, B.A. (1983). A study of one technique of guided imagery for the relief of terminal cancer pain. Unpublished master's thesis, California State University, Long Beach.

    Gaston-Johansson, F., Fall-Dickson, J.M., Nanda, J., Ohly, K.V., Stillman, S., Krumm, S., et al. (2000). The effectiveness of the comprehensive coping strategy program on clinical outcomes in breast cancer autologous bone marrow transplantation. Cancer Nursing, 23, 277-285.

    Glass, G.V. (1976). Primary, secondary, and meta-analysis of research. Educational Researcher, 5(10), 3-8.

    Glass, G.V., McGraw, M.L., & Smith, M.L. (1981). Meta-analysis in social research. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.

    Goodwin, P.J., Leszcz, M., Ennis, M., Koopmans, J., Vincent, L., Guther, H., et al. (2001). The effect of group psychosocial support on survival in meta-static breast cancer. New England Journal of Medicine, 345, 1719-1726.

    Graffam, S., & Johnson, A. (1987). A comparison of two relaxation strategies for the relief of pain and its distress. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management, 2, 229-231.

    Hedges, L.V., & Becker, B.J. (1986). Statistical methods in the meta-analysis of research on gender differences. In J.S. Hyde & M.C. Linn (Eds.), The psychology of gender (pp. 14-50). Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.

    Hedges, L.V., & Olkin, I. (1985). Statistical methods for meta-analysis. San Diego, CA: Academic Press.

    Jacox, A., Carr, D.B., & Payne, R. (1994). New clinical-practice guidelines for the management of pain in patients with cancer. New England Journal of Medicine, 330, 651-655.

    Jadad, A.R., & Browman, G.P. (1995). The WHO analgesic ladder for cancer pain management. Stepping up the quality of its evaluation. JAMA, 274, 1870-1873.

    Kerr, I.G. (1995). Clinical trials to study pain in patients with advanced cancer: Practical difficulties. Anticancer Drugs, 6(Suppl. 3), 18-28.

    Kusek, N.J. (1982). The effect of teaching on advanced cancer patients 'perception of pain. Unpublished master's thesis, University of Washington, Seattle.

    Kwekkeboom, K.L. (1999). A model for cognitive-behavioral interventions in cancer pain management. Image: Journal of Nursing Scholarship, 31, 151-156.

    Loitman, J.E. (2000). Pain management: Beyond pharmacology to acupuncture and hypnosis. JAMA, 283, 118-119.

    Maguire, P., Brooke, M., Tait, A., Thomas, C., & Sellwood, R. (1983). The effect of counseling on physical disability and social recovery after mastectomy. Clinical Oncology, 9, 319-324.

    Newell, S., & Sanson-Fisher, R.W. (2000). Australian oncologists' self-reported knowledge and attitudes about non-traditional therapies used by cancer patients. Medical Journal of Australia, 172, 110-113.

    Oliver, J.W., Kravitz, R.L., Kaplan, S.H., & Meyers, F.J. (2001). Individualized patient education and coaching to improve pain control among cancer outpatients. Journal of Clinical Oncology, 19, 2206-2212.

    Pan, C.X., Morrison, R.S., Ness, J., Fugh-Berman, A., & Leipzig, R.M. (2000). Complementary and alternative medicine in the management of pain, dyspnea, and nausea and vomiting near the end of life. A systematic review. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management, 20, 374-387.

    Rhiner, M., Ferrell, B.R., Ferrell, B.A., & Grant, M.M. (1993). A structured nondrug intervention program for cancer pain. Cancer Practice, 1, 137-143.

    Rimer, B., Levy, M.H., Keintz, M.K., Fox, L., Engstrom, P.F., & MacElwee, N. (1987). Enhancing cancer pain control regimens through patient education. Patient Education and Counseling, 10, 267-277.

    Rosenthal, R. (1979). The "file drawer problem" and tolerance for null results. Psychological Bulletin, 86, 638-641.

    Rosenthal, R. (1994). Parametric measures of effect size. In H. Cooper & L.V. Hedges, (Eds.) The handbook of research synthesis (pp. 231-244). New York: Russell Sage Foundation.

    Scallion, L.E. (1981). Relaxation training for patients with chronic cancerpain. [Abstract]. Proceedings of the Sixth Annual Congress of the Oncology Nursing Society, 89.

    Sellick, S.M., & Zaza, C. (1998). Critical review of 5 nonpharmacologic strategies for managing cancer pain. Cancer Prevention and Control, 2, 7-14.

    Sloman, R. (1995). Relaxation and the relief of cancer pain. Nursing Clinics of North America, 30, 697-709.

    Sloman, R., Brown, P., Aldana, E., & Chee, E. (1994). The use of relaxation for the promotion of comfort and pain relief in persons with advanced cancer. Contemporary Nurse, 3(1), 6-12.

    Smith, M.C., Holcombe, J.K., & Stullenbarger, E. (1994). A meta-analysis of intervention effectiveness for symptom management in oncology nursing research. Oncology Nursing Forum, 21, 1201-1209.

    Spiegel, D., & Bloom, J.R. (1983). Group therapy and hypnosis reduce meta-static breast carcinoma pain. Psychosomatic Medicine, 45, 333-339.

    Syrjala, K.L., Cummings, C., & Donaldson, G.W. (1992). Hypnosis or cognitive behavioral training for the reduction of pain and nausea during cancer treatment: A controlled clinical trial. Pain, 48, 137-146.

    Syrjala, K.L., Donaldson, G.W., Davis, M.W., Kippes, M.E., & Carr, J.E. (1995). Relaxation and imagery and cognitive-behavioral training reduce pain during cancer treatment: A controlled clinical trial. Pain, 63, 189-198.

    Thomas, E.M., & Weiss, S.M. (2000). Nonpharmacological interventions with chronic cancer pain in adults. Cancer Control, 7, 157-164.

    Trijsburg, R.W., van Knippenberg, F.C., & Rijpma, S.E. (1992). Effects of psychological treatment on cancer patients: A critical review. Psychosomatic Medicine, 54, 489-517.

    Twycross, R.G., & Fairfield, S.S. (1983). Symptom control in far advanced cancer: Pain relief. London: Pitman Books.

    van Fleet, S. (2000). Relaxation and imagery for symptom management: Improving patient assessment and individualizing treatment. Oncology Nursing Forum, 27, 501-510.

    Wallace, K.G. (1997). Analysis of recent literature concerning relaxation and imagery interventions for cancer pain. Cancer Nursing, 20, 79-87.

    Ward, S., Donovan, H.S., Owen, B., Grosen, E., & Serlin, R. (2000). An individualized intervention to overcome patient-related barriers to pain management in women with gynecologic cancers. Research in Nursing and Health, 23, 393-405.

    Wells, N. (2000). Pain intensity and pain interference in hospitalized patients with cancer. Oncology Nursing Forum, 27, 985-991.

    Zech, D.F., Grond, S., Lynch, J., Hertel, D., & Lehmann, K.A. (1995). Validation of World Health Organization guidelines for cancer pain relief: A 10-year prospective study. Pain, 63, 65-76.

    Zimmerman, L., Pozehl, B., Duncan, K., & Schmitz, R. (1989). Effects of music in patients who had chronic cancer pain. Western Journal of Nursing Research, 11, 298-309.