Underestimation of Breast Cancer Risk: Influence on Screening Behavior

Maria Katapodi

Marylin Dodd

Kathryn A. Lee

Noreen C. Facione

breast cancer diagnosis, cancer screening
ONF 2009, 36(3), 306-314. DOI: 10.1188/09.ONF.306-314

Purpose/Objectives: To describe perceived breast cancer risk, identify the percentage of women with inaccurate risk perceptions, and examine the influence of perceived and objective risk on screening behavior.

Design: Descriptive, correlational, cross-sectional.

Setting: Community settings in a metropolitan area on the western coast of the United States.

Sample: Multicultural sample of 184 English-speaking women (57% non-Caucasian, X age = 47 ± 12 years) who have never been diagnosed with cancer.

Methods: Two perceived risk scales (verbal and comparative) and the Gail model were used to assess perceived and objective breast cancer risk, respectively.

Main Research Variables: Perceived breast cancer risk, objective breast cancer risk, screening behavior.

Findings: Participants reported that they "probably will not" get breast cancer and that their risk was "somewhat lower" than average. Family history of breast cancer was a significant predictor of perceived risk. Demographic characteristics and objective risk factors were not associated with perceived risk. Most women at high risk for breast cancer (89%) underestimated their actual risk; fewer women with low to average risk for breast cancer (9%) overestimated their risk. Age, Gail scores, and health insurance status promoted breast cancer screening; underestimation of risk had the opposite effect.

Conclusions: Inaccurate perceptions of risk do not promote optimal breast cancer screening. The finding has implications for most women at high risk for developing breast cancer who underestimate their risk.

Implications for Nursing: Oncology nurses can use risk assessment tools to provide individualized counseling regarding breast cancer risk factors and screening. Women at high risk who underestimate their risk could benefit from additional screening and from advances in cancer chemoprevention.

Jump to a section


    Absetz, P., Aro, A.R., Rehnberg, G., & Sutton, S.R. (2000). Comparative optimism in breast cancer perception: Effects of experience and risk factor knowledge. Psychology, Health and Medicine, 5(4), 376-386.
    Aiken, L.S., Fenaughty, A.M., West, S.G., Johnson, J.J., & Luckett, T.L. (1995). Perceived determinants of risk for breast cancer and the relations among objective risk, perceived risk, and screening behavior over time. Women's Health, 1(1), 27-50.
    Alicke, M.D., Klotz, M.L., Breitenbecher, D.L., Yurak, T.J., & Vredenburg, D.S. (1995). Personal contact, individuation, and the above-average effect. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 68(5), 804-825.
    American Cancer Society. (2008). Cancer facts and figures 2008. Retrieved March 25, 2009, from
    American Society of Clinical Oncology. (1996). Genetic testing for cancer susceptibility. Journal of Clinical Oncology, 14(5), 1730-1736.
    Bondy, M.L., & Newman, L.A. (2003). Breast cancer risk assessment models. Cancer, 97(1, Suppl.), 230-235.
    Buxton, J.A., Bottorff, J.L., Balneaves, L.G., Richardson, C., McCullum, M., Ratner, P.A., et al. (2003). Women's perceptions of their breast cancer risk: Are they accurate? Canadian Journal of Public Health, 94(6), 422-426.
    Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2002). Behavioral risk factor surveillance system: 2001 survey questions. Retrieved December 5, 2002, from
    Chlebowski, R.T., Col, N., Winer, E.P., Collyar, D.E., Cummings, S.R., Vogel, V.G., et al. (2002). American Society of Clinical Oncology technology assessment of pharmacologic interventions for breast cancer risk reduction including tamoxifen, raloxifene, and aromatase inhibition. Journal of Clinical Oncology, 20(15), 3328-3343.
    Clarke, V.A., Lovegrove, H., Williams, A., & Machperson, M. (2000). Unrealistic optimism and the health belief model. Journal of Behavioral Medicine, 23(4), 367-376.
    Constantino, J.P., Gail, M.H., Pee, D., Anderson, S., Redmond, C.K., Benichou, J., et al. (1999). Validation studies for models projecting the risk of invasive and total breast cancer incidence. Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 91(18), 1541-1581.
    Cummings, S.R., Eckert, S., Krueger, K.A., Grady, D., Powles, T.J., Cauley, J.A., et al. (1999). The effect of raloxifene on risk of breast cancer in postmenopausal women: Results from the more randomized trial. JAMA, 281(23), 2189-2197.
    Daly, M.B., Lerman, C., Ross, E., Schwartz, M.D., Sands, C.B., & Masny, A. (1996). Gail model breast cancer risk components are poor predictors of risk perception and screening behavior. Breast Cancer Research and Treatment, 41(1), 59-70.
    Davids, S.L., Schapira, M.M., McAuliffe, T.L., & Nattinger, A.B. (2004). Predictors of pessimistic breast cancer risk perceptions in a primary care population. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 19(4), 310-315.
    Diefenbach, M.A., Weinstein, N.D., & O'Reilly, J. (1993). Scales for assessing perceptions of health hazard susceptibility. Health Education Research, 8(2), 181-192.
    Dolan, N.C., Lee, A.M., & McGrae-McDermott, M. (1997). Age-related differences in breast carcinoma knowledge, beliefs, and perceived risk among women visiting an academic general medicine practice. Cancer, 80(3), 413-420.
    Euhus, D.M., Leitch, A.M., Huth, J.F., & Peters, G.N. (2002). Limitations of the Gail model in the specialized breast cancer risk assessment clinic. Breast Journal, 8(1), 23-27.
    Facione, N.C. (2002). Perceived risk of breast cancer: Influence of heuristic thinking. Cancer Practice, 10(5), 256-262.
    Fisher, B., Costantino, J.P., Wickerham, D.L., Redmond, C.K., Kavanah, M., Cronin, W.M., et al. (1998). Tamoxifen for prevention of breast cancer: Report of the national surgical adjuvant breast and bowel project p-1 study. Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 90(18), 1371-1388.
    Gail, M., & Rimer, B. (1998). Risk-based recommendations for mammographic screening for women in their forties. Journal of Clinical Oncology, 16(9), 3105-3114.
    Gail, M.H., Brinton, L.A., Byar, D.P., Corle, D.K., Green, S.B., Schairer, C., et al. (1989). Projecting individualized probabilities of developing breast cancer for white females who are being examined annually. Journal of the National Cancer Institute Monographs, 81(24), 1879-1886.
    Gail, M.H., & Constantino, J.P. (2001). Validating and improving models for projecting the absolute risk of breast cancer. Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 93(5), 334-335.
    Gurmankin-Levy, A.S., Jr., Williams, S.V., Quistberg, A., & Armstrong, K. (2006). Measuring perceptions of breast cancer risk. Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers and Prevention, 15(10), 1893-1898.
    Haas, J.S., Kaplan, C.P., Des Jarlais, G., Gildengoin, V., Perez-Stable, E.J., & Kerlikowske, K. (2005). Perceived risk of breast cancer among women at average and increased risk. Journal of Women's Health, 14(9), 845-851.
    Hughes, C., Lerman, C., & Lustbader, E. (1996). Ethnic differences in risk perception among women at increased risk for breast cancer. Breast Cancer Research and Treatment, 40(1), 25-35.
    Humphrey, L.L., Helfand, M., Chan, B.K., & Woolf, S.H. (2002). Breast cancer screening. Annals of Internal Medicine, 137(5, Part 1), 347-360.
    Kahneman, D., & Miller, D.T. (1986). Norm theory: Comparing reality to its alternatives. Psychological Review, 93(1), 136-153.
    Katapodi, M.C., Lee, K.A., Facione, N.C., & Dodd, M. (2004). Predictors of perceived breast cancer risk and the relation between perceived risk and breast cancer screening: A meta-analytic review. Preventive Medicine, 38(4), 388-402.
    Leventhal, H., Kelly, K., & Leventhal, E.A. (1999). Population risk, actual risk, perceived risk, and cancer control: A discussion. Journal of the National Cancer Institute. Monographs, 25(1), 81-85.
    Lipkus, I.M., Kuchibhatla, M., McBride, C.M., Bosworth, H.B., Pollak, K.I., Siegler, I.C., et al. (2000). Relationships among breast cancer perceived absolute risk, comparative risk, and worries. Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers and Prevention, 9(9), 973-975.
    McCaul, K.D., Branstetter, A.D., Schroeder, D.M., & Glasgow, R.E. (1996). What is the relationship between breast cancer risk and mammography screening? Health Psychology, 15(6), 423-429.
    McDonald, P.A., Thorne, D.D., Pearson, J.C., & Adams-Campbell, L.L. (1999). Perceptions and knowledge of breast cancer among African American women residing in public housing. Ethnicity and Disease, 9(1), 81-93.
    McQueen, A., Swank, P.R., Bastian, L.A., & Vernon, S.W. (2008). Predictors of perceived susceptibility of breast cancer and changes over time: A mixed modeling approach. Health Psychology, 27(1), 68-77.
    Messick, D.M., Bloom, S., Boldizar, J.P., & Samuelson, C.D. (1985). Why are we fairer than others? Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 21(5), 480-500.
    Metcalfe, K., & Narod, S. (2002). Breast cancer risk perception among women who have undergone prophylactic bilateral mastectomy. Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 94(20), 1564-1569.
    National Cancer Institute. (2002). Breast cancer risk assessment tool (BCRAT). Retrieved April 23, 2004, from
    Reddy, P., & Chow, M.S. (2000). Safety and efficacy of antiestrogens for prevention of breast cancer. American Journal of Health System Pharmacy, 57(14), 1315-1322.
    Sabatino, S.A., Burns, R.B., Roger, B.D., Phillips, R.S., Chen, Y., & McCarthy, E.P. (2004). Breast carcinoma screening and risk perception among women at increased risk for breast carcinoma: Results from a national survey. Cancer, 100(11), 2338-2346.
    Svenson, O. (1981). Are we all less risky and more skillful than our fellow drivers? Acta Psychologica, 47(2), 143-148.
    Teigen, K.H., & Brun, W. (2000). Ambiguous probabilities: When does p = .3 reflect a possibility, and when does it express a doubt? Journal of Behavioral Decision Making, 13(3), 345-362.
    Weinstein, N.D. (1984). Why it won't happen to me: Perceptions of risk factors and susceptibility. Health Psychology, 3(5), 431-457.
    Weinstein, N.D. (1987). Unrealistic optimism about susceptibility to health problems: Conclusions from a community-wide sample. Journal of Behavioral Medicine, 10(5), 481-500.
    Weinstein, N.D. (1988). The precaution adoption model. Health Psychology, 7(4), 355-386.
    Weinstein, N.D., & Klein, W.M. (1995). Resistance of personal risk perceptions to debiasing interventions. Health Psychology, 14(2), 132-140.
    Weinstein, N.D., & Nicolich, M. (1993). Correct and incorrect interpretations of correlations between risk perceptions and risk behaviors. Health Psychology, 12(3), 235-245.
    Windschitl, P.D., Martin, R., & Flugstad, A.R. (2002). Context and the interpretation of likelihood information: The role of intergroup comparisons on perceived vulnerability. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 82(5), 742-755.
    Woloshin, S., Schwartz, L.M., Black, W.C., & Welch, H.G. (1999). Women's perceptions of their breast cancer risk: How you ask matters. Medical Decision Making, 19(3), 221-229.